Which DAZ Genesis 3 M and F characters are the most realistic?

12346

Comments

  • JOdelJOdel Posts: 6,322

    Amy, Lana, Marie, and Maya (and their male counterparts), were the gold standard for years. And deservedly so. All of them hold up very well with a bit of tweaking. Lana was ported over to Genesis as part of the starter essentials, for that matter.

    But we are still talking 3DL and at least five years ago. The tech has changed, and the very fact that the tweaking is necessary underscores this.

    It is *good* tech. But it is still *old* tech. We are not yet to the point that the tweaks and hoops to jump through make using any of them more trouble than it's worth. But we will eventually reach that point. One needs to at least pay attention to the direction that things appear to be moving, whether one choses to move at the same time or not. Ignoring the trends is a good way to find yourself stranded.

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,097

    The thing is, good texture maps are going to work decently until the tech significantly changes.

    The baked in lighting in color maps was deprecated long before Iray came on the scene, that was the biggest shift.

    Most of the less usable textures (like bump map = desaturated diffuse map) weren't done properly from the beginning, it was just less noticeable or simply tolerated.

    And so until the resolution demands increase more or the underlying technology -really- changes (like vector placement of features and more coded elements to a skin), I don't think skins are going to be outmoded for quite some time. Barring simple UV incompatibility.

  • mal3Imagerymal3Imagery Posts: 714
    edited June 2017

    Here's my two cent.  You can still make some nice realistic renders with old figures.  I don't know why you would need super ultra res photos to get nice results or the fact you need photoscans, it'll just take up to much memory. And I also think to many users want the make art button.  You need to put some effort in understanding how to use the application and how stuff interact.  Here's a render I did using the m4 base figure with m4 merchant skin.  It still looks great for being a very old product.

    M4Test.jpg
    1000 x 1300 - 1M
    Post edited by mal3Imagery on
  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,830
    edited June 2017

    Hmmm. I don't think they actually want to use super hi-res photos in the 3D model or rendering of the model itself but instead what they want is more complex surface material zones and 'PBR micromaterials' created/generated from such hi-res photos (and by the way they are using more than 'regular light' now to create such reference materiels) for ease of variance and uniqueness. And they want those correctly defined in PBR for use in the iRay shader renderings. And they want a UI that makes sense to a 5 year old playing dolls.

    In the same way DAZ has made it easy (well easier) to apply morphs (although it's not so simple to me if you look at a morph that has been applied from every angle and often find that it's just not working from some angles) so to do they want to easily configure unique skins for their characters that are one offs to their own personal project goals. 

    It is really a reasonable goal given what DAZ is and that each individual is trying to create their personalized art, personalized graphic novel, personalized animation, although I admit personally I am more of a tech nerd so I mainly am interested in seeing that although far too lazy and untrained to think my curiosity is going to lead me to make a significant contribution to the technical implementation.

    If the majority of DAZ hobbyists wanted to become competent amateurs to the point of being able to create their own textures sets and geometries then really those customers should be asking why even bother with the expense of DAZ products? Blender is free.

    Post edited by nonesuch00 on
  • FSMCDesignsFSMCDesigns Posts: 12,851

    Here's my two cent.  You can still make some nice realistic renders with old figures.  I don't know why you would need super ultra res photos to get nice results or the fact you need photoscans, it'll just take up to much memory. And I also think to many users want the make art button.  You need to put some effort in understanding how to use the application and how stuff interact.  Here's a render I did using the m4 base figure with m4 merchant skin.  It still looks great for being a very old product.

     

    Couldn't agree more.

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,830

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896

    Curious about things, dragged out V4 Amy to give her a spin with NGS Anagenessis. While, as usual, the V4 joints are a bit subpar, and the skin is a little flat even with all the tricks, it's pretty nice. And there are some really nice eyes on the older stuff.

    Not Reby Sky, but hey.

    The question is "Which DAZ G3 M and F character is the best?"..  That is a whole other topic that is unrelated and nothing to do with the topic at hand..

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,830

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

    Because the skin textures on them are better the the more blurred, Reba Sky style air-brushed models. Also, although Stormy is your typical female model beauty, Dale & Kimo are not so typically male models. They look authentically like 'character actors'.

    Not much more reason than that. It comes down to unique body and face geometries and unique skin texture sets created for those characters. Others have stated why they like other Genesis 3 models best.

    By the way the easiest way to up the 'realism' in the eyes of the average viewer is to increase the strength of the 'bump' and 'normal' maps, although personally I think a lot of times it is way too strong in some popular examples. It is a matter of personal taste.

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896

     Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

    Because the skin textures on them are better the the more blurred, Reba Sky style air-brushed models. Also, although Stormy is your typical female model beauty, Dale & Kimo are not so typically male models. They look authentically like 'character actors'.

    Not much more reason than that. It comes down to unique body and face geometries and unique skin texture sets created for those characters. Others have stated why they like other Genesis 3 models best.

    By the way the easiest way to up the 'realism' in the eyes of the average viewer is to increase the strength of the 'bump' and 'normal' maps, although personally I think a lot of times it is way too strong in some popular examples. It is a matter of personal taste.

    I have to say that I like you have very interesting tast and I strongly agree with you about Dale and Kimo...

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

    Because the skin textures on them are better the the more blurred, Reba Sky style air-brushed models. Also, although Stormy is your typical female model beauty, Dale & Kimo are not so typically male models. They look authentically like 'character actors'.

    Not much more reason than that. It comes down to unique body and face geometries and unique skin texture sets created for those characters. Others have stated why they like other Genesis 3 models best.

    By the way the easiest way to up the 'realism' in the eyes of the average viewer is to increase the strength of the 'bump' and 'normal' maps, although personally I think a lot of times it is way too strong in some popular examples. It is a matter of personal taste.

    I own "Dale" so you inspired me to go back and take another look... You're right on the money with that call.... Thanks for that.  I am curious as to how changing the maps increases the realism... maybe somebody out their has the time and knowledge to talk about this in more details. 

    Stormy is an interesting chioce... I wonder if anybody has any examples ... none of the promo pictures on her page really enticed me to want to own that character.

    dal34c.jpg
    1288 x 575 - 580K
  • FSMCDesignsFSMCDesigns Posts: 12,851
    edited June 2017

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

    Because the skin textures on them are better the the more blurred, Reba Sky style air-brushed models. Also, although Stormy is your typical female model beauty, Dale & Kimo are not so typically male models. They look authentically like 'character actors'.

    Not much more reason than that. It comes down to unique body and face geometries and unique skin texture sets created for those characters. Others have stated why they like other Genesis 3 models best.

    By the way the easiest way to up the 'realism' in the eyes of the average viewer is to increase the strength of the 'bump' and 'normal' maps, although personally I think a lot of times it is way too strong in some popular examples. It is a matter of personal taste.

    This is a perfect example of why this thread is flawed, everyone has their own tastes.  The exact reasons you mention Stormy are the reasons why I don't hardly use her, too basic and monotone looking on the textures. She is a good character, but to basic and flat looking IMO.

    While I am sure there are better looking textures out there, one of my go to texture sets is Mother and Daughters from Anain at rendo. Here is a comparision with Stormy with basic GF3, no HD morphs. Stormy on the right

    As for female shape, I use my own morphs, never use any of the packaged ones. For addon characters, I have to say V7, Genevive and Ophelia are the ones I like the most

    characater.jpg
    963 x 1080 - 871K
    Post edited by FSMCDesigns on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,097
    edited June 2017

    Yeah, I like a lot more detail, like the one on the left, because it looks more... real to me. But some people WANT glamor airbrushed-looking models, particularly for women.

    I normally don't worry about it too much because I have Skin Overlay for G2 and Skin Builder 3 for G3 to add more detail, and Aging/Vascularity/Muscularity to add lots of HD details.

    On a related note, some people prefer highly glossy/greasy looking models, while I prefer something more on the dry side with some natural glossy bits.

    It depends on your goals; I like rendering people in real scenes (or weird versions of real scenes), other people want pin ups, etc.

     

    Post edited by Oso3D on
  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,830

    OK, I will post example. I am currently rendering a corny scene for the milk props freebie in the PC+ section of the forums with the LY Stormy skin texture with the Bethany 7 morph shape and the Dale texture with the Brian (3) combined with Hunter (5) Head morph shapes which is part of the LY Distictive HD Faces and Bodies morphs Lyoness released recently.

    I do admit the the LY Stormy skin texture is model flawless but it is not so blurred and capable of showing fine details, albiet it details a Dove Soap model would have...but still. 

    I don't use Dale's acne scar textures and I avoid dialing up the details too much as it then emphasizes some unique skin properties of Dale that others have already used.

    The main thing that draws me to a texture when I buy it is, is it a skin tone other than this generic California tan that is so easy to get in the DAZ Store. Dale, Kimo, and Stormy all meet that criteria for me. Skin is more than just light to dark; there are quite a few color hues for skin that are valid and subtle but hardly ever available.

    When my render is finished I will post it here but it will be a while as I am CPU rendering volumetric milk in the scene from MEC4D's vol 2 iRay shaders. Currently it looks like to me an image a meticulous painter might do more than a realistic photograph. In the DAZ world I've only found few renders that are momentarily looking realistic. It's an OK render although I'm as usual not entirely happy with the face expressions and other aspects. Oh, does DAZ need a new cow and/or do I need to learn to create my own textures that are good, lol, one of the two...or both.

    For good rendering tutorials that are simple you should do the tutorials here:

    http://thinkdrawart.com/

     

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,097

    Nice thing about SB3 is that if a model is too 'perfect' you can fix that. :)

     

  • FauvistFauvist Posts: 2,290

    "I don't want reality, I want magic." ~ Tennessee Williams from Streetcar Named Desire

  • wolf359wolf359 Posts: 3,946

    "Nice thing about SB3 is that if a model is too 'perfect' you can fix that. :)"

    This particularly useful for story telling narratives in animation that call for Characters living under "less than ideal " conditions.

    I just wish there were more options for 
    cracked dry heels,lips and chipped nails with dirt under them. 

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,097

    Hmm. You know, Genesis 3 has the nice feature that the fingers are solid objects apart from the nails, so there might be some possibilities with placing stuff between the two. Worth experimenting with.

     

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896

    Here's my two cent.  You can still make some nice realistic renders with old figures.  I don't know why you would need super ultra res photos to get nice results or the fact you need photoscans, it'll just take up to much memory. And I also think to many users want the make art button.  You need to put some effort in understanding how to use the application and how stuff interact.  Here's a render I did using the m4 base figure with m4 merchant skin.  It still looks great for being a very old product.

    I think you are absolutely right on the money... The characters skin is the most important aspect of creating realism and this m4 merchant skin is amazing looking and you've done a brilliant render.  You have clearly illustrated your point and I agree wholeheartedly on your opinion concerning realistic looking characters. In fact, some of my favorite characters are still V-4 characters.  If the goal was simply a realistic skin, then of course, we have zero need to ever update since we already have a massive library of amazing skins on a decade old character...  BUT...

    The question I asked is "Which DAZ Genesis 3 character looks the most real' because while your character certainly has its uses... and nobody is saying that they don't.. He is entirely incapable a reproducing complex human expressions that Gen 3 can... that area that most often forgotten because V4 lacks the articulation points that are the very reason I bothered to basically restart my collection in favor of the updated characters.    I've tried converting my v-4 skins to Genesis 3 but it simply doesn't fit.  So now.. I cherry pick the best of the best out of the new line up which brings me back to the very reason I started asking about Gen 3.  You 'very old product' is good but I'm looking for the best of whats new.  Thanks

    nino5b.jpg
    1288 x 575 - 285K
  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896
    Mattymanx said:

    Some very cool choices but all 4 of them have a massive library of characters... so imagine that you are brand new to the market and you have a budget under a hundred dollars but you want to make the best choice from all that line up... Which characters do you pick out of that huge line up... It's not like I'm a millionaire who can afford the entire collection... help me choose the best of the best.  What do you say?  Thanks in advance.

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896
    edited June 2017

    This discussion is getting rather aggressive and confrontational - please dial it back and respect the other participants.

    Yes, I hope that people keep the conversation focused on answering the initial question of which Genesis 3 characters are the most real... The whole reason I asked is that it helps me to cherry pick the best of the best out of DAZ's library.... Instead I'm getting a history lesson.  By asking this question, I hope to sort out a lot of more pedestrian varieties without being negative about it.  So whats your answer?  Which one do you feel is the most realistic G3 character?

    For the guys: Dale or Kimo

    For the gals: LY Stormy

    They sound like interesting recommendations... Please show me more than just a few names.. tell me why.. what stands out about them to you?  Show me why if you can.. if you don't mind.  Thank you for sharing in advance.  There a hundreds of chioces out there.. why do those names stick out for you?

    Grateful

    Because the skin textures on them are better the the more blurred, Reba Sky style air-brushed models. Also, although Stormy is your typical female model beauty, Dale & Kimo are not so typically male models. They look authentically like 'character actors'.

    Not much more reason than that. It comes down to unique body and face geometries and unique skin texture sets created for those characters. Others have stated why they like other Genesis 3 models best.

    By the way the easiest way to up the 'realism' in the eyes of the average viewer is to increase the strength of the 'bump' and 'normal' maps, although personally I think a lot of times it is way too strong in some popular examples. It is a matter of personal taste.

    This is a perfect example of why this thread is flawed, everyone has their own tastes.  The exact reasons you mention Stormy are the reasons why I don't hardly use her, too basic and monotone looking on the textures. She is a good character, but to basic and flat looking IMO.

    While I am sure there are better looking textures out there, one of my go to texture sets is Mother and Daughters from Anain at rendo. Here is a comparision with Stormy with basic GF3, no HD morphs. Stormy on the right

    As for female shape, I use my own morphs, never use any of the packaged ones. For addon characters, I have to say V7, Genevive and Ophelia are the ones I like the most

    Looking at buying the one on the left.... Wow. See.. a good looking skin like that sells itself. 

    Post edited by SnowPheonix on
  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,830
    Mattymanx said:

    Some very cool choices but all 4 of them have a massive library of characters... so imagine that you are brand new to the market and you have a budget under a hundred dollars but you want to make the best choice from all that line up... Which characters do you pick out of that huge line up... It's not like I'm a millionaire who can afford the entire collection... help me choose the best of the best.  What do you say?  Thanks in advance.

    Cailin seems the most popular from my casual observations of what others have said.

  • FSMCDesignsFSMCDesigns Posts: 12,851
     

    Simply brilliant.. which character is on the left?  I want to make sure and buy that one... Wow.

    https://www.renderosity.com/mod/bcs/mother-and-daughters-for-g3f/115836

     

  • SnowPheonixSnowPheonix Posts: 896
    Fauvist said:

    "I don't want reality, I want magic." ~ Tennessee Williams from Streetcar Named Desire

    Love that quote.  To me, the goal is to create reality and make that magic.... otherwise you are just making cartoon magic.  Give me the real magic. 

    Mattymanx said:

    Some very cool choices but all 4 of them have a massive library of characters... so imagine that you are brand new to the market and you have a budget under a hundred dollars but you want to make the best choice from all that line up... Which characters do you pick out of that huge line up... It's not like I'm a millionaire who can afford the entire collection... help me choose the best of the best.  What do you say?  Thanks in advance.

    Cailin seems the most popular from my casual observations of what others have said.

    imageShow me a render... Sell me on Cailin... I have to admit that she looks pretty good in some of the promo shots that I've seen but show me why she's your contender for 'the best of the best'  #respect  Come fly with me... :)

    dancers4b.jpg
    1288 x 575 - 465K
  • MattymanxMattymanx Posts: 7,000
    Mattymanx said:

    Some very cool choices but all 4 of them have a massive library of characters... so imagine that you are brand new to the market and you have a budget under a hundred dollars but you want to make the best choice from all that line up... Which characters do you pick out of that huge line up... It's not like I'm a millionaire who can afford the entire collection... help me choose the best of the best.  What do you say?  Thanks in advance.

    Personal favorite from each:

    https://www.daz3d.com/millie-for-aiko-7

    https://www.daz3d.com/p3d-chandra-hd-for-victoria-7

    https://www.daz3d.com/cathy-hd-for-victoria-7

    https://www.daz3d.com/isa-for-rune-7

     

     

  • seeker273seeker273 Posts: 449

    I really love the new boys by JavierMichael, Arran and Isamu. They are gorgeous and a bit ethnic which I like a lot.

    And if you're still looking for a super realistic guy, then check out Gregory by Tempesta3D over at the other store. My jaw dropped when I saw him!

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,097

    The Exile skin is AMAZING.

     

    ... What?

     

  • nicsttnicstt Posts: 11,715

    .

    Mattymanx said:

    Some very cool choices but all 4 of them have a massive library of characters... so imagine that you are brand new to the market and you have a budget under a hundred dollars but you want to make the best choice from all that line up... Which characters do you pick out of that huge line up... It's not like I'm a millionaire who can afford the entire collection... help me choose the best of the best.  What do you say?  Thanks in advance.

    https://www.daz3d.com/n-g-s-anagenessis-2-revolution

    https://www.daz3d.com/skin-builder-3-for-genesis-3-female-s

    https://www.daz3d.com/cailin-for-victoria-7

    https://www.daz3d.com/chiyo-for-victoria-7

    Characters are great; two of my favourites are here, but I also make my own from scratch, as well as altering ones I have.

    Sometimes the best characters aren't the ones with the most detail, but ones with less - they are easier to alter.

  • RayztoneRayztone Posts: 17

     

     Skin is more than just light to dark; there are quite a few color hues for skin that are valid and subtle but hardly ever available.

    Some people have nearly flawless skin, but most do have a lot of different hues in different areas of their face. The below render is G3F and the skin texture is from a woman who has a much less than perfect complexion. 

    My question is how much detail is too much? Where is the line for what is attractive and when does realism start to become undesirable? My take is that DAZ and their PA's have a pretty good sense of what people actually want and what sells.

     

    hues.jpg
    960 x 960 - 764K
Sign In or Register to comment.