No encrypted for me.

1272830323341

Comments

  • HavosHavos Posts: 5,575
    Morpheon said:
    icecrmn said:
    Morpheon said:
    icecrmn said:
    They didn't try to hide anything from the very start.

    Or they simply tried to get ahead of the inevitable s***-storm that would have ensued had people discovered that their assets WERE being encrypted and DAZ hadn't said anything at all -- kind of like the backlash Smith Micro got when people discovered they were getting locked out of Poser. That's CYA, not honesty. 

    You and I have very different veiws on what constitutes honesty.

    Honesty is what you do simply because it's the right thing to do -- CYA is merely damage control, and I've seen nothing from all this to suggest it's anything other than CYA. DAZ simply doesn't want to get tarred-and-feathered (metaphorically speaking) in addition to sparking a customer exodus.

    And I'm still trying to get an answer to my earlier question: what is Plan B if the encryption is busted wide open or if sales tank? The allegedly increasing piracy situation that supposedly neccesitated DRM will presumably still exist in either case, so what will DAZ do if their Plan A fails? I'd really like to know.

     

    Plan B if indeed your doom and gloom scenario becomes true is DAZ would desist, at least for a while, from releasing encrypted products. I doubt they would remove the functionality enabling it though, not much point after you have spent the time putting it in, and they could always reactivate at a more opportune moment. However I suspect sales will stay overall flat (unless there is normal organic growth they would have gotten anyway), and in this case the encryption experiment would continue with a "Nothing lost, nothing gained" attitude.

  • wgdjohnwgdjohn Posts: 2,634
    edited January 2016

    There are still certain effects and materials that I need to render in Poser although I use DAZ Studio and Reality for other things. Nevertheless, not being able to import .duf files into Poser at all any more severly limits their value for me. I had still been buying some G3 content, hoping that eventually comatibility might be achieved again but that seems to be a lost cause by now. I should really cancel my subscription, or perhaps buy a few remaining older items before doing so. Bad feelings about this overall, and judging by the number of views and replies to this discussion, it is not exactly only a select few customers who are annoyed by this move.

    As a previous Poser user this doesn't sound good. I had been planning on upgrading Poser. Guess DAZ wants Studio to be the only choice on the block for their content. I've already limited use of Genesis 1 and 2 and absolutly no Genesis 3 use for Carrara. If DAZ continues down this road they will use any Poser or future program like it.

    Post edited by wgdjohn on
  • I couldn't find any way to force it to reacquire that metadata. I could use the content by going through folders but when I went to reimport metadata nothing showed up. Trying to use the cloud folder as a runtime was... Tedious as hell.

    And now the 'reinstall' process of the previously installed content evidently gets really slow after a hundred or so products so I have to close Studio and reopen it to continue... And of course each one has to start by confirming with servers that I own it so it can 'reinstall' the content already on my hard drive.  I'm thinking it'd be easier to dump all the folders into a single runtime again. I'd at least have some use of them.

  • Salem2007Salem2007 Posts: 513
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Will Daz Studio always be free? 

    I can't say "yes" with absolute certainty, but I'd love to see DAZ try to put a price tag on it again after the way they burned everyone who paid for DAZ Studio 4 Advanced and Pro, only to give it away free to everyone about two months later. Now THOSE would be some interesting sales numbers.

    I remember those days all too well.  I guess I have to trust Daz to not make me pay for DS featues that I currently have in the future if I have encrypted content.  Trust....it's a slippery slope.

  • MorpheonMorpheon Posts: 738
    edited January 2016
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Will Daz Studio always be free? 

    I can't say "yes" with absolute certainty, but I'd love to see DAZ try to put a price tag on it again after the way they burned everyone who paid for DAZ Studio 4 Advanced and Pro, only to give it away free to everyone about two months later. Now THOSE would be some interesting sales numbers.

    I remember those days all too well.  I guess I have to trust Daz to not make me pay for DS featues that I currently have in the future if I have encrypted content.  Trust....it's a slippery slope.

    Can you imagine the commercial in that scenario?

    "Yes, when you want your content encrypted and a nagging suspicion that the application you're paying hundreds of dollars for today will be given away free to everyone in just a few short weeks (because they already did it once before), then you want DAZ Studio 4.9+. Pre-order NOW!"

    Who could pass up an offer like that?

    Post edited by Morpheon on
  • Salem2007Salem2007 Posts: 513
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Will Daz Studio always be free? 

    I can't say "yes" with absolute certainty, but I'd love to see DAZ try to put a price tag on it again after the way they burned everyone who paid for DAZ Studio 4 Advanced and Pro, only to give it away free to everyone about two months later. Now THOSE would be some interesting sales numbers.

    I remember those days all too well.  I guess I have to trust Daz to not make me pay for DS featues that I currently have in the future if I have encrypted content.  Trust....it's a slippery slope.

    Can you imagine the commercial in that scenario?

    "Yes, when you want your content encrypted and a nagging suspicion that the application you're paying hundreds of dollars for today will be given away free to everyone in just a few short weeks (because they already did it once before), then you want DAZ Studio 4.9+. Pre-order NOW!"

    And people think the situation NOW is getting over-heated...

    I imagine something like: We encrypted your content to make it easier to find.  Now we're making it easier to use with the new Daz Studio Elite!  DS Elite will open your encrypted content to make it even easier to render....and it's free if you buy the new Victoria 8 for only $99.99---today only!  And if you buy the Victoria 8 Pro bundle we'll waive the monthly log-in fee and give you genitals for free!

  • lx_2807502lx_2807502 Posts: 2,996
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Will Daz Studio always be free? 

    I can't say "yes" with absolute certainty, but I'd love to see DAZ try to put a price tag on it again after the way they burned everyone who paid for DAZ Studio 4 Advanced and Pro, only to give it away free to everyone about two months later. Now THOSE would be some interesting sales numbers.

    I remember those days all too well.  I guess I have to trust Daz to not make me pay for DS featues that I currently have in the future if I have encrypted content.  Trust....it's a slippery slope.

    Can you imagine the commercial in that scenario?

    "Yes, when you want your content encrypted and a nagging suspicion that the application you're paying hundreds of dollars for today will be given away free to everyone in just a few short weeks (because they already did it once before), then you want DAZ Studio 4.9+. Pre-order NOW!"

    And people think the situation NOW is getting over-heated...

    I imagine something like: We encrypted your content to make it easier to find.  Now we're making it easier to use with the new Daz Studio Elite!  DS Elite will open your encrypted content to make it even easier to render....and it's free if you buy the new Victoria 8 for only $99.99---today only!  And if you buy the Victoria 8 Pro bundle we'll waive the monthly log-in fee and give you genitals for free!

    This is quite clearly a fiction.

     

    Daz would say "Anatomical Elements."

  • Salem2007Salem2007 Posts: 513
    lx said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Morpheon said:
    Salem2007 said:
    Will Daz Studio always be free? 

    I can't say "yes" with absolute certainty, but I'd love to see DAZ try to put a price tag on it again after the way they burned everyone who paid for DAZ Studio 4 Advanced and Pro, only to give it away free to everyone about two months later. Now THOSE would be some interesting sales numbers.

    I remember those days all too well.  I guess I have to trust Daz to not make me pay for DS featues that I currently have in the future if I have encrypted content.  Trust....it's a slippery slope.

    Can you imagine the commercial in that scenario?

    "Yes, when you want your content encrypted and a nagging suspicion that the application you're paying hundreds of dollars for today will be given away free to everyone in just a few short weeks (because they already did it once before), then you want DAZ Studio 4.9+. Pre-order NOW!"

    And people think the situation NOW is getting over-heated...

    I imagine something like: We encrypted your content to make it easier to find.  Now we're making it easier to use with the new Daz Studio Elite!  DS Elite will open your encrypted content to make it even easier to render....and it's free if you buy the new Victoria 8 for only $99.99---today only!  And if you buy the Victoria 8 Pro bundle we'll waive the monthly log-in fee and give you genitals for free!

    This is quite clearly a fiction.

     

    Daz would say "Anatomical Elements."

    Good point...and it would never be $99.99--that would be the price AFTER the 30% off.  I'm glad it's only fiction...wink

  • MorpheonMorpheon Posts: 738
    edited January 2016
    lx said:
    This is quite clearly a fiction.

     

    Daz would say "Anatomical Elements."

    I know, right? "genitals" -- "genitalia" -- what the heck are THOSE, anyways? Now "Anatomical Elements" -- EVERYBODY understands what that means, right?

    DAZ trying to fix something that wasn't broken to begin with.

    Post edited by Morpheon on
  • lx_2807502lx_2807502 Posts: 2,996

    This is semi unrelated, but does have to do with leaving to less-encrypted pastures: The founder person who was an expert at anatomical drawing left Daz and made his own "most accurate figure ever" but then also stated that it would never be available with genitalia. So as silly as the whole "Anatomical Elements" thing is, Daz has at least been making its figures steadily more complete each generation (except G3M which was a bit of a backtrack.)

    Anyone want to place a wager against the next generation of Anatomical Elements being encrypted, though?

  • There have been some really way-out-there ideas of what people think is going on.  I realize that most of the fears and horror stories are connected with games and music and such.  I've seen my share of stuff of this stuff in one form or another, but I try to take things on a case by case basis.

    I have a subscription to Mudbox, Maya, and Adobe Photoshop/Lightroom.  I have to authorize my computers with Pixologic and for 3D Coat.  I have an easier time registering if I'm online when I do Modo, Allegorithmic and other products.  I had Substance Painter on Steam.  I'm used to it.  I even expect to go online to do certain things.  It's not a hassle.  I've never had a bad experience with any of them.  Occasionally, Pixologic needs me to do a bit more footwork.  No big deal.  And maybe it's no big deal to me because I don't let it be.

    I tried working with the Connect only products over the weekend to see what all the hoopla was about.  I could export,  I could reimport.  I could save out scenes, subsets, files of all types.  I could create duplicates of user-interfacing files to change and do what I needed, save and reuse them.  The particular scripts I have are working fine.  I tried out the new Smart Content and while I have much to learn to do whatever I choose to do, I'm finding it very interesting to work with.

    I see people say that they're being prevented from doing things in Studio; I just don't see what those things are.  There's no impediments to doing morphs or ERC, certainly nothing stopping production of textures or poses or much else.  Perhaps there are some things and I haven't run into them.  I don't know; people don't say much more than generalizations.  I'm sure there are bugs, but they need to be logged to be addressed.

    So that's been my experience thus far, no real mess, business as usual.

    A subscription service is very different from purchased content.  You expect to lose access to your rented software when the rent period is over.  You are doing business on a month-to-month or year-to-year basis.  When you buy art assets, you expect them to always be there.  When you rely on a network, it's unclear how long they will be there.  The even bigger issue, though, is what will happen moving forward to the purchases you make today.  New policies next year will imediately be applied to content you buy today.  If your hard drive/motherboard breaks, what happens to the content you purchased?  If your hard drive/motherboard breaks next year, will the policy be the same or will they have edited their policies next year such  that if your hard drive/otherboard breaks you've just lost all your content?  What will the policies and procedures be for getting to the content you buy today in two years?  I don't know, and that's the problem.  There's no telling what you're buying, because what you're buying can change at any time in the future.  You have access to the content you buy at the policies they have today until they tell you otherwise.  You will simply live with whatever policy changes they make in the future being applied to all of your purchases from now till then.  I suppose I'm more willing to put up with it in the case of Steam because I trust Valve more.  That and I tend to play a game to competition and then move on to something else.  I think that's where business is headed.  As corporations maintain control over everything they sell you forever, that question of how much you trust a company matters more and more.  When Daz can change the way you get to content you've already purchased and change the way you use it and change anything about your access to the content you bought at any time they want you have to ask how much you trust Daz.

  • Arcane Von OblivionArcane Von Oblivion Posts: 149
    edited January 2016
    tl155180 said:
    ghosty12 said:

    Even some of the other 3D content sites are starting to mock this DRM stance..  Recieved a email from one of them today promoting that their content is and will always be DRM free, and part of their promotion was giving a discount code to all their members..

    Yeah, I've had this email too this morning. It made me chuckle. Trying to cash in on what they obviously hope will be Daz's DRM-related demise. Very cheeky, but very funny.

    I must admit... also very tempting.

    I paid for the Daz Studio 4, and Carrara "promises". Still waiting for the Dynamic clothes maker, hair and HD morphs and might have even updated were it not encyption making it so I can't control my own stuff. March madness about 3 years ago I purchaced everything I needed to get a pick of M5, the Supersuit, or a grab bag of items directly sent from Daz to my house. Do you know what they sent me? Someones desk that they cleaned out. With stuff like a light kinda like a lava lamp and 50 CD's worth of the same Akido installs (50 of the same CD!).. I mean this was Junk they sent me and went through the trouble to send it to my house after I spent all that money. Read this how you like but they don't care if they do then they have a funny way of showing it. I bet they erase this. So let me get to my point of the thread. Not for me, no way No how. "No encrypted for me". I was buying but I'm not now. Let the newbies find out for them selves. But my history with them is very bad except that I like there software and G1. But the software isn't all there doing and they don't seem to be doing much with it except for using it as a cow.

     

    6 or 7 Character releases for every version of Genesis at $75 PC price for the PRo version and its now close to $100. thats $700 for each Generation of Genesis or more so like $1500 times the amount of people that buy these things which arent upgrades but instead "new" figures for a new Base. And I'm still using Genesis 1 and some of you are using V$ yet...lol come on!

    Post edited by Arcane Von Oblivion on
  • Serene NightSerene Night Posts: 17,704

    DAZ connect is not showing items I've purchased. I picked up troubadour for Gen 2 males and textures and they have not showed up in my Connect. I bought those yesterday. They show up in my product library just not my connect client.

  • icecrmn said:
    Trake118 said:
    Mattymanx said:
    jpb06t said:

    Thouroughly backuped on 4 hard disks and 4 CD-ROMs everything I ever got from DAZ and I advise everbody to do so.

    Why?

     

    There is nothing in Daz Studio 4.9 that will alter you excisting content automatically.  The encrypted content will be for new content moving forward only and the encryped content you buy will ALWAYS be available through YOUR account for ANY future version of Daz Studio 4.9+ that you have installed.

    I understand that this is the policy for today, but it wasn't long ago that Daz said they had no plans on making encryption only content.  I have no idea as to what Daz's policies are going to be tommarow.  Better safe than sorry.  Policies change constantly.  What's available and the terms of availability of any content through a cloud service or encryption change constantly.  The only thing you really have is what's on your hard drive backed up in a format you can run without authentication.  Everything is something you have for however long policies stay the same. 

     

    Let me put this plainly.  Whatever content you have that isn't in simple files on your computer Daz can disable any time they want without warning.  Products can become obsolete.  Things can get dropped.  Policies can change.  With the new sysem, new policies can be instituted to imediately apply to every piece of content you have except for what's on your hard drive in unencrypted files.  Question is: EXACTLY how much do you trust Daz not to change their policies?

    I'm not singling you out, so please don't feel that way.

    There are many 3D modeling programs that use a proprietary file format that only the programs they sell can even read, let alone open and modify.Autodesk's suite of creation tools come to mind immediately,though they aren't the only ones that use a proprietary file format. This is why there are so many compatibility formats used in exporters for 3D art programs. It seems that everyone has their own file format they use for their programs because they all want to save data in a different way that best suites the needs for their programs. Daz Studio also has many of these formats available in their file exporter, just as these other 3D creation tools do. You would be right in claiming that some programs offer more variety in the export formats they offer than others.DS does have a number of the most common ones that don't require that we buy a separate license for.

    Daz COULD have simply announced that they were altering their file format in a way to better suite the needs of Studios data structure. That really would have been no different than what we have had in all versions of Studio anyway. You can't open a DS formatted 3D asset in very many other programs. There just aren't that many other programs that want to use the duf or other DS file formats. This would have avoided the whole "encryption is DRM" discussion.

    Daz chose to instead be very transparent about the whole decision to encrypt some files that weren't encrypted already. Yes, many of your DS files have been encrypted for years. .I see this as a very trust worthy decision on their part. They didn't try to hide anything from the very start. For very obvious reasons they can't go into great details as to how the encryption system works. That is a standard policy though. Your bank will not give you the operational details of the encryption system they use to secure your bank account either.

    So, when you ask me if I trust Daz to not lock me out of the 3D assets I have purchased from them at some some time in the future. I will say yes, I do trust them. I do not believe that Daz will ever lock me out of any thing that I have legitimate access to. They ( Daz ) have given me every reason to trust them because of the actions they have taken in regards to this change.

    File format differences are about adding some feature.  For an instance, many of them allow the file to record actions taken so you can load a file and press undo and actually start undoing commands.  That's not the same thing as encryption.  Depending on your licencing with Maya you could disconnect from the internet and load a file you created in Maya.  You could also just save it as an OBJ.  This means that you'll always have access to that art asset you made.  It's different when you need to connect to a network to access your art asset.  That's primarily what this is about.  When you need to access that network to load an art asset (something that isn't the case with the file format for Maya (MB)), that means that future policies can be applied in the future to purchases made today.  I don't know that I trust that they aren't going to tie my licence to my motherboard serial number or hard drive data  I'm also not sure for how long they will continue to support content and what happens when they drop support for content. 

    I'm not trying to tell you who you should trust/not trust.  I absolutely respect your decition to trust them.  I'm just saying that this is now a MUCH more trust dependent relationship than it was before and how the nature of purchases have changed.  I think everyone needs to know fundamentally how this changes the nature of every purchase.  Honestly, it's more about tieing your purchases to a cloud network service than it is the encryption.  The encryption is really more a means of tieing you to the network.

    I can remember them saying not long ago that they had no plans to make purchases encryption only.  I tend to question if that was an honest statement. 

  • MorpheonMorpheon Posts: 738
    lx said:

    This is semi unrelated, but does have to do with leaving to less-encrypted pastures: The founder person who was an expert at anatomical drawing left Daz and made his own "most accurate figure ever" but then also stated that it would never be available with genitalia. So as silly as the whole "Anatomical Elements" thing is, Daz has at least been making its figures steadily more complete each generation (except G3M which was a bit of a backtrack.)

    Anyone want to place a wager against the next generation of Anatomical Elements being encrypted, though?

    That's a sucker bet -- you're not taking my money that easily.

  • wgdjohnwgdjohn Posts: 2,634
    Leana said:
    Now don't get me wrong, I don't exactly like the fact that they changed their mind on day 1 either. I can't say that I'm surprised by the "here are a few freebies / low cost items that work only with the new system, to make you try it" tactic though.

    They changed their minds before day 1. I may be wrong  but suspect they knew this was going to take place but didn't share it with everyone. The fact that there is already so much DRM and Connect ONLY content available indicates this to me. As I've stated before when DIM and manual downloads go away so do I.

  • lx_2807502lx_2807502 Posts: 2,996
    wgdjohn said:
    Leana said:
    Now don't get me wrong, I don't exactly like the fact that they changed their mind on day 1 either. I can't say that I'm surprised by the "here are a few freebies / low cost items that work only with the new system, to make you try it" tactic though.

    They changed their minds before day 1. I may be wrong  but suspect they knew this was going to take place but didn't share it with everyone. The fact that there is already so much DRM and Connect ONLY content available indicates this to me. As I've stated before when DIM and manual downloads go away so do I.

    Ehhh. Obviously the decision was made before the release day, but I seriously doubt it takes them long to pick some upcoming content and encrypt it now that the system has been created. A lot of the "free" stuff screams "intended for PC+" so they probably bought it out ages ago since they have content lined up well in advance of release.

  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609

    If DAZ goes the way that products are connect and encrypted only products I will spend no more money here at the store (and I have spend thousands over the last years). If DAZ want me to spend no more money at their store, I will do so and will not spend more money.

  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609

    If DAZ goes to hell (disappears from the scene) - what happens then with this new content (connect and encypted) if I buy a new machine and want to use DAZ on the new machine? I guess the new content will not work then.

    The same with the DAZ software, if DAZ disappears from the scene how can we install DAZ software on a new machine and make it running?

  • SnowSultanSnowSultan Posts: 3,773

    Can we please try not panicking about DAZ "going to hell" less than a week after the first bit of encrypted content is released?

  • Um, this is an important question to have answered given the new direction they've chosen.

     

    As far as I've heard there's some plan for some kind of full unlock in the event the company shuts down. Stories vary from 'we have one ready if necessary' to 'we're still working on it'. But at least for now they seem to have some idea of what precautions to take. After all, no company can ever say that they can't fail. Too many much bigger and stronger ones have.

  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609
    edited January 2016

    Can we please try not panicking about DAZ "going to hell" less than a week after the first bit of encrypted content is released?

    It is just a question what happens then. If I would spend so much money for encrypted products as I have spend for "normal" products (thousands of dollars) I would be worry about this issue.

    Post edited by cosmo71 on
  • fred9803fred9803 Posts: 1,565

    This has been discussed at length before and I don't think Daz has any plans to fold. In the unlikely event that might happen, I would trust them to provide a way to unencrypt previously encrypted content before they did. Raising worst case scenerios based on hypertheticals is the last thing we need at the moment.

  • KindredArtsKindredArts Posts: 1,332
    cosmo71 said:

    If DAZ goes to hell (disappears from the scene) - what happens then with this new content (connect and encypted) if I buy a new machine and want to use DAZ on the new machine? I guess the new content will not work then.

    The same with the DAZ software, if DAZ disappears from the scene how can we install DAZ software on a new machine and make it running?

    I don't really want to get into the on-going battle (It was so nice and peaceful a week ago :( ) - But, they have said they are implementing a failsafe which would unlock encrypted content in the event of daz's demise. I think it was Steve that put that out there, but i've seen the idea come up a few times.

  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609

    This has been discussed at length before and I don't think Daz has any plans to fold. In the unlikely event that might happen, I would trust them to provide a way to unencrypt previously encrypted content before they did. Raising worst case scenerios based on hypertheticals is the last thing we need at the moment.

    yes but I am not the only one I think who worries about that issue. It is money. And if you buy things you want to use them independently from the company you have bought them from.

  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609
    edited January 2016

    If this independently use of bought products is not possible, then they should not sell the products but just rent/lease the products to us. BTW it would not be a surprise to me right now if DAZ goes that way in the future. pay per use laugh

    Post edited by cosmo71 on
  • cosmo71cosmo71 Posts: 3,609
    edited January 2016

    You better tone that down a tad cosmos. It's actually not that bad. As I siad above... disappointing, not the end of the world as we know it.

    BTW it would not be a surprise to me right now, if DAZ goes the way "pay per use" in the future because If independently use is not possible, then they should not sell the products but rent them to us.

    Post edited by cosmo71 on
  • fred9803fred9803 Posts: 1,565

    When you buy any Daz products you undertake to install it on only one machine anyway, it's in the EULA. As to the rent/lease idea, some think that's a future possibility like other software providers have done. Daz say they have no plans to do so. Not that their "no plans" phrase hasn't been contradicted before. And that's a different worry in itself.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,847
    Daikatana said:
    kyoto kid said:

    ...nice, but somewhat more period styled (30s Cthulu investigator) and a bit out of my budget. I just need a "generic" trench coat

    I sure hope this isn't going to become an ongoing  trend with DO content, or staying  in the PC will no longer be worth the cost.

    Yeah.  This occurred to me while looking at the various options this morning .  There's still the PA content related coupon though.

    I used to do the bulk of my 3D shopping here at DAZ because they often DO have the best content but now with this encryption situation having evolved, it's starting to appear that I will spend more time -and more money elsewhere.

    I simply can't understand why a company will take a stance that alienates a good chunk of its long term customers as well as put itself in a vulnerable position as regards to its competitors and simply not care.  Are they TRYING to put themselves out of business?

     

    ...already used that earlier this month.

  • fred9803fred9803 Posts: 1,565

    Not that I like the situation, but if you buy a CD of DVD you only have limited rights to "independent use". Have you seen all those warnings that appear before the movie starts? Can't copy, can't share etc. of what some think they own outright by buying it. That's exactly the same as the EULA for Daz products. By buying it you only have limited rights of what you can do with it, and that doesn't include "independent use" to do anything you want.

This discussion has been closed.