3D Print

245

Comments

  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945
    edited March 2017

    Speaking of Warhammer figures...

    It's about 2.25" tall, when it was first printed, it was enclosed in a shroud of peel away plastic to support the ovehangs. And watching hiom print he has the same grid inside as the previous picture. According to Cura (the slicing program) hit takes about 18grams of plastic.

    image

    IMG_20170308_202421.jpg
    1440 x 2560 - 1M
    Post edited by Chohole on
  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    I've been doing a lot of experimenting with my settings to get a good miniature print, but most printers come with a 0.4mm print nozzle and you really need something smaller. The smallest I think I've seen is 0.15 but the smaller the nozzle, the easier it is to get clogged. I'm going to try a 0.2 nozzle and see how that works.

  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945

    Something else ive been thinking about is undercuts. Im assuming that an average 3d printer cuts on a vertical and horizontal axis. I imagine that if you have a 3d printer that is accurate enought to cut out the upper palate on a models open mouth(if possible), your probably paying a vast amount of money for a maintenance high machine. So im just going to consider horizontal and vertical cut planes. When considering flash and undercuts, is it good practice to create your own surfaces as to avoid severe undercuts? For example, an open mouth. Would it be practical to place a sphere in an open mouth that is more or less flush with the back of the teeth? That way its less intensive a cut for the machine? Then you can just cut away the sphere or paint it black or whatever serves your purpose.

    When daz first started advertising 3d print, I noticed that gen 2 was usually listed as 3d print ready. What makes g2f/m 3d print ready and what do you have to do in order to make g3f/m 3d print ready. Can you make any of dazs models 3d print ready? What does that process involve? More software? Sorry, im really excited about this prospect!

    Actually the printer can cover a small gap withou support, so you could probably do an open mouth. The arch of the mouth would support itself.

    The print ready part was for older software that couldn't stand single sided objects.

  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945

    I've been doing a lot of experimenting with my settings to get a good miniature print, but most printers come with a 0.4mm print nozzle and you really need something smaller. The smallest I think I've seen is 0.15 but the smaller the nozzle, the easier it is to get clogged. I'm going to try a 0.2 nozzle and see how that works.

    According to the manual my machine has a 0.1 mm layer height, with a 0.4 mm nozzle size.

  • nemesis10nemesis10 Posts: 3,861

    But if it's your printer, why would that matter? I mean, I can copy content from one of my pcs to another.

    it is one of those things like if you play your radio in a stadium of people, you are listening to your radio but if you play your radio for a stadium of people, ASCAP comes and demands that you pay royalties.  The issue isn't the printing; it is the selling.... which has to be negotiated like any other intellectual property.  The 2d image rights have already be worked out but the 3d rights haven't been.

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090

    'We haven't worked out the rights' is perfectly understandable, I was just looking askance at the notion that there's some underlying essential reason not to do it that way.

    Nitpicking, perhaps.

  • nemesis10nemesis10 Posts: 3,861
    edited March 2017

    'We haven't worked out the rights' is perfectly understandable, I was just looking askance at the notion that there's some underlying essential reason not to do it that way.

    Nitpicking, perhaps.

    It seems nitpicky but I work sometimes with intellectual property and people get antsy about people messing with stuff that they don't have permission for.

    Post edited by nemesis10 on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090

    Oh, I mean maybe I'm being nitpicky. ;)

     

  • ChoholeChohole Posts: 33,604
    edited March 2017

    Oh, I mean maybe I'm being nitpicky. ;)

     

    Think about it,  you are a PA,  you have just spent 3 months totally building a fantasy figure from scratch and now it is being sold to Daz customers as a totally original figure,  then somebody comes along,  buys one copy while it's on sale and promptly runs of an amount on his cheap home 3d printer and flogs them at the local fleamarket,   Are you going to be pleased that someone else is coining in money based on your 3 months work and completely destroying the originality of your figure.  before you have even recouped a fraction of the expense?     

    And by expense I mean the fact that thsi has taken 3 months labout,  3 months with nothing coming in until the sale is a done deal.

     

     

    Post edited by Chohole on
  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945

    Chohole, isn't that the same as a PA creating a figure and someone using in as a book cover? The cover artist makes the money and the PA gets the single sale from them.

  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914
    edited March 2017
    Chohole said:

    Oh, I mean maybe I'm being nitpicky. ;)

     

    Think about it,  you are a PA,  you have just spent 3 months totally building a fantasy figure from scratch and now it is being sold to Daz customers as a totally original figure,  then somebody comes along,  buys one copy while it's on sale and promptly runs of an amount on his cheap home 3d printer and flogs them at the local fleamarket,   Are you going to be pleased that someone else is coining in money based on your 3 months work and completely destroying the originality of your figure.  before you have even recouped a fraction of the expense?     

    And by expense I mean the fact that thsi has taken 3 months labout,  3 months with nothing coming in until the sale is a done deal.

     

     

    Personally, I would not be upset. What I am selling is a completely customizable virtual product that can be used in a multitude of projects and has many uses.

    What they have done and are now selling is a static physical prop that has very limited uses. It's either going to sit on a shelf and look pretty or it's going to be used in tabletop games. completely unrelated to the product I am selling except by in looks.

     

    *edit*

    In addition, the most a home 3d printer can do is 2 colors at the moment so someone would have to smooth the model down and hand paint it for any type of detail. Which also brings up the point that any details, bumps or displacements from textures is lost in the the 3d print as it only prints the bare mesh.

    Post edited by kaotkbliss on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090
    edited March 2017

    How is that materially different from some bozo putting my work in an uncreative basic pose and selling prints?

    How does that appropriate or cut into my business in any way? I'm not in the business of selling physical product, so what competition is it providing?

     

     

    Post edited by Oso3D on
  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945

    BTW: I didn't mean to create an argument or anything. I just think it's neat that you can print something like this at home.

  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    I don't see any arguments ;) just a bunch of discussion and speculating on the reasonings for the current restrictions.

  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    I actually forgot about the game license thing and I think you are right, that is probably the way they will go for 3d printing. Though I do hope they aren't as costly as the game licenses.

  • GreybroGreybro Posts: 2,602
    Chohole said:
    Greybro said:
    Chohole said:

    So if you own your own 3D printer, are you allowed to sell the finish product like at Comic-Cons and stuff?

    NO.   The EULA says it is for personal use only. 

     

    The creation of three-dimensional physical representations (3D-print, molded copy, CNC-routed copy, and the like) of Content or any three-dimensional art derived from the Content is permitted only for personal, non-commercial use by the User. Additionally, the user may not grant other entities or individuals the right to produce such physical representations of the Content except for the sole purpose of providing the print to the User for their personal use.

    Chohole, have I ever mentioned how often your Avatar gif makes me chuckle? It's like your are the fun police sometimes!

    When i was first umm   volunteered for upgrading to forum mod I decided that I needed a new avatar,  did that one as a joke and asked some on line friends, who thought it was grand, but needed a handbag.  I am not the hadnbag type so added the club.  got instant thumbs up all round and Daz_Ann offered to animate it for me,  and I have had it ever since.   They won't let me change my name, although we moved out of Chohole Gate Lodge more than 8 years ago, and they tell me I mustn't change the avatar either.

    You're AVATAR choice skills have peaked early. DON'T EVER CHANGE IT!

  • FSMCDesignsFSMCDesigns Posts: 12,846
    Chohole said:

    Oh, I mean maybe I'm being nitpicky. ;)

     

    Think about it,  you are a PA,  you have just spent 3 months totally building a fantasy figure from scratch and now it is being sold to Daz customers as a totally original figure,  then somebody comes along,  buys one copy while it's on sale and promptly runs of an amount on his cheap home 3d printer and flogs them at the local fleamarket,   Are you going to be pleased that someone else is coining in money based on your 3 months work and completely destroying the originality of your figure.  before you have even recouped a fraction of the expense?     

    And by expense I mean the fact that thsi has taken 3 months labout,  3 months with nothing coming in until the sale is a done deal.

     

     

    Well said!! yes

  • BruganBrugan Posts: 365
    edited March 2017

    EDIT: I don't know if I'd go that far, personally I'd like to see the whole thing simplified, but I understand it's a business and we do get a pretty steep discount to use the materials for 2D considering the time that goes into some of the content here. There's other websites out there that sell you comparable content with all rights included, but the prices are astronomical (in the thousands).

     

    Post edited by Brugan on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090

    If the agreement was 'you cannot sell artwork derived from this work to anyone named Timothy', then sure, that's the rights.

    There is also a discussion about what it 'should' be, what is sensible, and what is ideal.

     

    I don't think it makes sense to restrict which format artistic output comes out in, with the exception of output that makes it trivially easy to copy/disseminate the original content itself. I also don't think it's a good idea to restrict this content or paygate it, because you are essentially discouraging people from buying your content on something that's a risky commerce anyway.

    At the end of the day, it IS limited, so of course 'don't do that.' And I can certainly understand the potential legalese barriers, given 'legal' and 'sensible' are casual acquaintances at best.

     

  • jestmartjestmart Posts: 4,449
    edited March 2017

    I think the problem is what nemesis10 alluded to, how to write an agreement allowing 3D prints that doesn't create a loophole for people to 'steal' the mesh rights.

    Post edited by jestmart on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090

    Jestmart: The thing is... how exactly does that happen?

    I mean, if I prepare a scene for 3d printing, at the very least I have to convert the stuff to an obj file. Which means if the figure had any rigging, morphs, or different material options, all those go away.

    And IP wise, if you have the right to print something on a 2d printer or 3d printer, how exactly is that stealing rights to the content?

     

    It just... doesn't add up.

     

  • ChoholeChohole Posts: 33,604

    The geometry is still there,  the mesh that makes up the model.

     

  • jestmartjestmart Posts: 4,449

    Because a 3D print is a derivative of the 3D mesh which of course a 2d print isn't.

  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    The thing is, Say I pose then print a figure in 3d. I give that figure to someone and they take a 3d scanner and scan it (which would be the only way they could get the mesh from a physical object I 3d print at home) What they end up with will #1 be of a completely different mesh (geographs, textures and morphs will not work with this figure) #2 the detail will be a lot lower quality than the original 3d model (so much so that it's probably not even worth the effort to try and scan it) and #3 size of their model will not be the same so re-rigging and re-texturing will be a big pain

    And all that doesn't even take into consideration overlapping parts that may come from a pose, which they will then have to cut and fill in the holes in a 3d modeling app after they scan it.

    So even still, if they do all that, they will still not have the original model. Only something that looks vaguely like the original.

  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945
    edited March 2017

    Actually, the STL meshes don't look like the OBJ meshes, but I get the point that they're similar in appearance.

    It's like Decimator meshes, no internals, but also no bones, no mats.

    I'm at work so I can't show you a comparison right now.

    Post edited by MarcCCTx on
  • frank0314frank0314 Posts: 14,741

    Wait, we can use Daz to render 2D stuff that we sell, but we can't print out 3D figures to sell?

    That's... weird.

     

    If you wish to sell the 3D Prints you need to contact Daz to see if they will allow it but the EULA does say that you can't sell the 3D prints.

  • DzFireDzFire Posts: 1,473

    Some of us PAs are already selling our 3D prints and is part of our business plan. Allowing other 3D prints of the same thing to be sold hamper our sales or violates contracts we have with other vendors. Daz3D sells the license to use the models in 2D artwork for personel or commercial works. The 3D models still belong to us, either the PAs or Daz, and the 3D prints are a whole other marketplace.

  • MarcCCTxMarcCCTx Posts: 945

    Where is the marketplace for Printable 3D? I curious now.

    Thiniverse is cool, but what are the other options?

    Also DAZ, why haven't gotten into this aspect of the business?

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,090
    edited March 2017

    Nm, either people understand what I'm saying or not, and it doesn't really matter.

     

    Post edited by Oso3D on
  • KA1KA1 Posts: 1,012
    Interesting, a 3d print thread started 5days after I ordered a DIY kit and 3 days before it arrived! Will probably join in the discussion once it's built or more importantly I guess is if I get it working...oh and calibrated and upgrades printed and...hmm maybe there'll be new threads by then!!
This discussion has been closed.