features for a new computer

Hi everyone. After updating daz 4.11 my computer gives me a series of errors that at the moment were not solved even with the support of the daz team. I came to the conclusion of buying a new computer just to work with daz. I can't work with him for more than 2 weeks ... and I miss him.pianto
I ask you if you can advise me of the technical features (processor, nvidia card, ram etc.) to let me build a computer to make fast and optimized renderings. Thanks to everyone for the precious advices smiley

«13

Comments

  • DripDrip Posts: 1,237

    Wait another week, and the new Ryzen chips should be available. Just make sure the motherboard matches the CPU.

    For the rest:
    - 16+ GB of RAM. 32 would be better though.
    - GPU: Either an RTX2060+ (for rendering, the RTX2070 is definitely a useful upgrade with its extra VRAM, though an RTX2080 or 2080Ti would be great if you can afford it) or a second hand GTX1070/1080. Professional GPU's like Titans are an entirely different ballpark, no experience with those here.
    Most RTX cards only have HDMI ports and one or more USB-ports (for VR). Just mentioning that detail incase you still connect to your monitor through an older VGA cable or something.
    - If you're getting a new case, make sure to get one with multiple fans and airfilters pre-installed. Look up the manufacturers' website if you have to. I've seen bloody expensive ($150+) cases with space for 5 fans, but only 1 installed in the rear. But there are also very decent cases with 3 fans pre-installed at a third of that price. Also note that very few of the newest cases even have space for things like optical disk readers.
    - Liquid or aircooling doesn't really make a big difference, as long as it's a good cooler for your situation. As noisy or quiet as you like. If you want to overclock your CPU or unlock a higher clockrate on your RAM, your CPU will need better cooling than the standard AMD cooler. Intel CPUs always need a better cooler than they're delivered with (if they even come with a default cooler at all! They generally don't come with a standard cooler, and when they do, it's pretty bad even for a non-overclocked rig)
     

    Useful extra: a hotswap drivebay. Even if you build your own computers and have no trouble installing a HDD, these things can be convenient for several purposes.

  • dannagiusy64dannagiusy64 Posts: 477

    Damn, thanks, but I don't have all this money to spend. sorpresa 

    Drip said:

    Wait another week, and the new Ryzen chips should be available. Just make sure the motherboard matches the CPU.

    For the rest:
    - 16+ GB of RAM. 32 would be better though.
    - GPU: Either an RTX2060+ (for rendering, the RTX2070 is definitely a useful upgrade with its extra VRAM, though an RTX2080 or 2080Ti would be great if you can afford it) or a second hand GTX1070/1080. Professional GPU's like Titans are an entirely different ballpark, no experience with those here.
    Most RTX cards only have HDMI ports and one or more USB-ports (for VR). Just mentioning that detail incase you still connect to your monitor through an older VGA cable or something.
    - If you're getting a new case, make sure to get one with multiple fans and airfilters pre-installed. Look up the manufacturers' website if you have to. I've seen bloody expensive ($150+) cases with space for 5 fans, but only 1 installed in the rear. But there are also very decent cases with 3 fans pre-installed at a third of that price. Also note that very few of the newest cases even have space for things like optical disk readers.
    - Liquid or aircooling doesn't really make a big difference, as long as it's a good cooler for your situation. As noisy or quiet as you like. If you want to overclock your CPU or unlock a higher clockrate on your RAM, your CPU will need better cooling than the standard AMD cooler. Intel CPUs always need a better cooler than they're delivered with (if they even come with a default cooler at all! They generally don't come with a standard cooler, and when they do, it's pretty bad even for a non-overclocked rig)
     

    Useful extra: a hotswap drivebay. Even if you build your own computers and have no trouble installing a HDD, these things can be convenient for several purposes.

     

  • JamesJABJamesJAB Posts: 1,766

    Then here are the questions you need to answer before anyone can give advice that you can actualy use...

    1.  What CPU, RAM, and GPU are in your current computer

    2.  What is your budget?

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805

    Actually post every detail you know about your current system and how much you want to spend. I can figure out a viable build given those paramenters.

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805
    Drip said:


    Most RTX cards only have HDMI ports and one or more USB-ports (for VR). Just mentioning that detail incase you still connect to your monitor through an older VGA cable or something.
     

    Every RTX card should have one or more DisplayPort connectors as well as HDMI, some will even have DVI if anyone still has a monitor that needs that.

  • CricketCricket Posts: 477

    I have the same quesitons. Assuming price isn't an issue, what would be the best build?

  • TheKDTheKD Posts: 2,711

    RTX SUPER™ Series is coming this month too

  • rrwardrrward Posts: 556
    TheKD said:

    RTX SUPER™ Series is coming this month too

    Nvidia just released the specs. Nice bumps for the 2060, 2070, and 2080 (not 20180 ti). Looks like some price drops for their old lineup while suuplies last as well.

  • For the two people asking, what is your budget?  It's very difficult for anyone to help you if they don't know this.

  • CricketCricket Posts: 477

    Around $2,500.

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805

    I'm going to hold off on providing a build until Sunday. The Ryzen 3000 CPU's and Navi GPU's drop then and the CPU's could greatly effect prices.

  • ebergerlyebergerly Posts: 3,255

    I'm going to hold off on providing a build until Sunday. The Ryzen 3000 CPU's and Navi GPU's drop then and the CPU's could greatly effect prices.

    Just curious...how can you provide a recommendation for a new computer build without knowing what the OP's will be doing with the computer (aside from DAZ renderings), as well as what he/she is expecting in terms of performance, what other apps they use, whether they need portability, etc.?

  • retiretomauiretiretomaui Posts: 392

    Just curious...how can you provide a recommendation for a new computer build without knowing what the OP's will be doing with the computer (aside from DAZ renderings), as well as what he/she is expecting in terms of performance, what other apps they use, whether they need portability, etc.?

    The thread starter said that he was building a new PC, "just to work with Daz," so I think we can assume that graphics and rendering are the top priority.  If a new PC can run Daz and render like a beast, then it can likely run any other app or program he's likely to be using. He also said nothing about portability, so that would obviate the new PC being a laptop. 

    I went Ryzen 2700X last Christmas and haven't looked back. If the thread starter can afford to wait just a little bit, I'd save up for a 3000 series Ryzen and a serious GPU.

     

  • CricketCricket Posts: 477

    I would actually prefer a laptop but would like advice either way

  • JamesJABJamesJAB Posts: 1,766
    Escape said:

    I would actually prefer a laptop but would like advice either way

    Choose one with at least 16GB of RAM and a GTX 1070, RTX 1070, GTX 1080, or RTX 1080 and you will be in a good place for Daz Studio and Iray rendering.

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805
    Escape said:

    I would actually prefer a laptop but would like advice either way

    If you want a lappie you're giving up a lot of performance but if you want it get a gaming lappie with the best Nvidia GPU you can afford. There are quite a few 2080 equipped machines for $2500. 

  • edited July 2019

    For a render dedicated desktop, and you are willing to wait for a good sale, you can find something like this from Cyberpower (priced today).  It's not a gaming machine, and mounts a core I5 but it should do a good job at rendering as you don't need a state of the art CPU.  One thing to consider, if you go with a RTX2000 series GPU, they are releasing the 2nd generation cards (Super) which are significantly better than the current ones.

    Pro Influencer 300 (NO MONITOR)
    $1827

    • *BASE_PRICE: [+2519]
    • Summer Featured Promotions: None
    • Gaming Chassis: Phanteks Evolv X ATX Mid-Tower Gaming Case Anodized Aluminum, USB-Type C & Full-size Swing Tempered Glass Panel Window + ARGB (Satin Black)
    • Laser Engraving: None
    • Laser Engraving Message: None
    • Lighting: None
    • Extra Case Fans: 3X 120mm Case Fans for your selected case [+9]
    • CPU: Intel® Core™ Processor i5-7640X Quad-Core 4.0GHz 6MB Intel Smart Cache LGA2066 (Dual Channels) [-924]
    • Venom Boost Fast And Efficient Factory Overclocking: Pro OC (Performance Overclock 10% or more) [+19]
    • CPU / Processor Cooling Fan: CyberPowerPC MasterLiquid Lite 120mm ARGB CPU Liquid Cooler with Dual Chamber Pump & Copper Cold Plate
    • Coolant for Cyberpower Xtreme Hydro Water Cooling Kits: None
    • Motherboard: ASUS TUF X299 MARK 2 ATX w/ RGB, USB 3.1, 3 PCIe x16, 1 PCIe x4, 2 PCIe x1, 6 SATA3, 2 M.2 SATA/PCIe [Intel Optane Ready]
    • RAM / System Memory: 32GB (8GBx4) DDR4/3000MHz Quad Channel Memory [+84] (ADATA XPG Z1)
    • Video Card: GeForce® RTX 2070 8GB GDDR6 (Turing) [VR Ready] (Single Card)
    • Freebie of Video Card: None
    • Sli Bridge: None
    • EVGA Power: None
    • HTC VIVE Virtual reality Headset: None
    • Video Capture Card: None
    • Power Supply: 800 Watts - Standard 80 Plus Gold Certified Power Supply
    • Primary Hard Drive: 512GB Intel® 660P SERIES PCIe NVMe M.2 SSD - Seq R/W: Up to 1500/1000 MB/s, Rnd R/W up to 90/220k (Single Drive)
    • Secondary Hard Drive: 6TB (6TBx1) SATA-III 6.0Gb/s 64MB Cache 7200RPM HDD [+81] (Plus 32GB Intel Optane Memory HDD Acceleration 24X Faster (Secondary Storage Drive) [+39])
    • Hard Drive Cooling Fan: None
    • External Storage: None
    • Optical Drive: None
    • WiDi Router: None
    • Internal Wireless Network Card: None
    • Sound: HIGH DEFINITION ON-BOARD 7.1 AUDIO
    • Monitor: None
    • Projector: None
    • Cables: None
    • Speakers: None
    • Internal Network Card: Onboard Gigabit LAN Network
    • Keyboard: CyberPowerPC Multimedia USB Gaming Keyboard
    • Mouse: CyberPowerPC Standard 4000 DPI with Weight System Optical Gaming Mouse
    • Mouse Pad: None
    • Headset: None
    • Microphone: None
    • Gaming Apparel: None
    • Gaming Gear: None
    • Internal USB Expansion Module: None
    • Wireless Routers/Hubs: None
    • Video Camera: None
    • Power & Surge Protection: None
    • USB Hub & Port: Built-in USB 2.0 Ports
    • External Accessories: None
    • Operating System: Windows 10 Home (64-bit Edition)
    • Professional Wiring: None
    • Ultra Care Option: None
    • Warranty: STANDARD WARRANTY: 1 Year Parts WARRANTY
    • Service: 3 Years FREE Service Plan (INCLUDES LABOR AND LIFETIME TECHNICAL SUPPORT)
    • Rush Service: Standard processing time: ship within 5 to 10 Business Days
    • *_PRICE: (+1827)
    Post edited by davidwski_16294691f0 on
  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,850
    Escape said:

    I would actually prefer a laptop but would like advice either way

    ...I worked on a notebook for years before finally building a desktop system. The heat from rendering eventually burned out the keyboard to where I needed to use a wireless one (taking up one of the few USB ports I had left as I also had an external  trackball plugged in which was much more accurate than the tiny touch pad). 

    My strikes against using a notebook as the primary system include:  

    • Limited options for upgrading and maintenance (particularly for doing so yourself).
    • Limited configuration options. such as memory, multiple drives, and GPU.
    • Often inferior cooling (unless you purchase one of the expensive gaming models with dual fans and flow through venting and even that isn't as good as liquid cooling).
    • Smaller display. 
    • They often come bundled with "crapware". 
    • High cost for what you get as you sacrifice power/performance for portability.  

    Now as a secondary system for say when you are away from home and still want to play with Daz, that is different.  

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,850
    edited July 2019

    @ Davidwski  I would always opt for a hyperthreading CPU.  8 GB of VRAM is the basic optimal amount for most jobs but should rendering dump to the CPU, 4 cores will definitely be the bottleneck. Also with more threads you can dedicate a portion to other processes if you multitask.

    I would consider an 8 core/16 thread Ryzen7 2400X as they are not really all that much more expensive than the i5-7640X (which according to Intel has been discontinued) as well as has comparable clock speeds. (boost clock of 4.3GHz).

    Post edited by kyoto kid on
  • ebergerlyebergerly Posts: 3,255

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

     

  • JamesJABJamesJAB Posts: 1,766
    ebergerly said:

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

     

    You are correct.

    Though it is still dependent on how well the laptop manufacturer designes the cooling setup.  Modern GPUs in laptops will dynamicaly set the clock speed and fan speed based on load and temperature.  Also, you need to look out for mobile GPUs with the MAX-Q designator as these are clocked lower by default for slimmer laptops.

    A modern laptop should never get hot enough to burn out the keyboard or any other componenets (GTX 9x0, 10x0, 16x0 or RTX 20x0)

    Always ensure that your laptop is on a hard flat surface while rendering for optimal air flow into the fans

    Purchase a laptop with a dual fan setup if you plan on using it for rendering

    Honestly when looking ar pre-built computers, there is not much of a price gap between render(gaming) ready desktops and laptops any more.

    Most gaming laptops have a thunderbolt port nowdays.  This is great for adding an external GPU for rendering.

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805
    JamesJAB said:
    ebergerly said:

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

     

    You are correct.

    Though it is still dependent on how well the laptop manufacturer designes the cooling setup.  Modern GPUs in laptops will dynamicaly set the clock speed and fan speed based on load and temperature.  Also, you need to look out for mobile GPUs with the MAX-Q designator as these are clocked lower by default for slimmer laptops.

    A modern laptop should never get hot enough to burn out the keyboard or any other componenets (GTX 9x0, 10x0, 16x0 or RTX 20x0)

    Always ensure that your laptop is on a hard flat surface while rendering for optimal air flow into the fans

    Purchase a laptop with a dual fan setup if you plan on using it for rendering

    Honestly when looking ar pre-built computers, there is not much of a price gap between render(gaming) ready desktops and laptops any more.

    Most gaming laptops have a thunderbolt port nowdays.  This is great for adding an external GPU for rendering.

    Not exactly. The mobile versions of the Pascal and Turing GPU's are low powered versions of the corresponding desktop ones. They have the same CUDA count but much lower clock speed and other characteristics. This results in a roughly 20 to 25% lower GFLOPS for the mobile variants. And that assumes their is enough cooling to let the mobile GPU's run at base clock full time which is almost never the case. Even with those compromises the mobile chips still consume an awful lot of power making use of the laptop without being plugged in a very short term thing.

    Once you're efectively tethered to a wall outlet to even use the thing why not just build a PC (no one with any technical savvy should ever buy a prebuilt).

  • kenshaw011267kenshaw011267 Posts: 3,805

    For a render dedicated desktop, and you are willing to wait for a good sale, you can find something like this from Cyberpower (priced today).  It's not a gaming machine, and mounts a core I5 but it should do a good job at rendering as you don't need a state of the art CPU.  One thing to consider, if you go with a RTX2000 series GPU, they are releasing the 2nd generation cards (Super) which are significantly better than the current ones.

    Pro Influencer 300 (NO MONITOR)
    $1827

    • *BASE_PRICE: [+2519]
    • Summer Featured Promotions: None
    • Gaming Chassis: Phanteks Evolv X ATX Mid-Tower Gaming Case Anodized Aluminum, USB-Type C & Full-size Swing Tempered Glass Panel Window + ARGB (Satin Black)
    • Laser Engraving: None
    • Laser Engraving Message: None
    • Lighting: None
    • Extra Case Fans: 3X 120mm Case Fans for your selected case [+9]
    • CPU: Intel® Core™ Processor i5-7640X Quad-Core 4.0GHz 6MB Intel Smart Cache LGA2066 (Dual Channels) [-924]
    • Venom Boost Fast And Efficient Factory Overclocking: Pro OC (Performance Overclock 10% or more) [+19]
    • CPU / Processor Cooling Fan: CyberPowerPC MasterLiquid Lite 120mm ARGB CPU Liquid Cooler with Dual Chamber Pump & Copper Cold Plate
    • Coolant for Cyberpower Xtreme Hydro Water Cooling Kits: None
    • Motherboard: ASUS TUF X299 MARK 2 ATX w/ RGB, USB 3.1, 3 PCIe x16, 1 PCIe x4, 2 PCIe x1, 6 SATA3, 2 M.2 SATA/PCIe [Intel Optane Ready]
    • RAM / System Memory: 32GB (8GBx4) DDR4/3000MHz Quad Channel Memory [+84] (ADATA XPG Z1)
    • Video Card: GeForce® RTX 2070 8GB GDDR6 (Turing) [VR Ready] (Single Card)
    • Freebie of Video Card: None
    • Sli Bridge: None
    • EVGA Power: None
    • HTC VIVE Virtual reality Headset: None
    • Video Capture Card: None
    • Power Supply: 800 Watts - Standard 80 Plus Gold Certified Power Supply
    • Primary Hard Drive: 512GB Intel® 660P SERIES PCIe NVMe M.2 SSD - Seq R/W: Up to 1500/1000 MB/s, Rnd R/W up to 90/220k (Single Drive)
    • Secondary Hard Drive: 6TB (6TBx1) SATA-III 6.0Gb/s 64MB Cache 7200RPM HDD [+81] (Plus 32GB Intel Optane Memory HDD Acceleration 24X Faster (Secondary Storage Drive) [+39])
    • Hard Drive Cooling Fan: None
    • External Storage: None
    • Optical Drive: None
    • WiDi Router: None
    • Internal Wireless Network Card: None
    • Sound: HIGH DEFINITION ON-BOARD 7.1 AUDIO
    • Monitor: None
    • Projector: None
    • Cables: None
    • Speakers: None
    • Internal Network Card: Onboard Gigabit LAN Network
    • Keyboard: CyberPowerPC Multimedia USB Gaming Keyboard
    • Mouse: CyberPowerPC Standard 4000 DPI with Weight System Optical Gaming Mouse
    • Mouse Pad: None
    • Headset: None
    • Microphone: None
    • Gaming Apparel: None
    • Gaming Gear: None
    • Internal USB Expansion Module: None
    • Wireless Routers/Hubs: None
    • Video Camera: None
    • Power & Surge Protection: None
    • USB Hub & Port: Built-in USB 2.0 Ports
    • External Accessories: None
    • Operating System: Windows 10 Home (64-bit Edition)
    • Professional Wiring: None
    • Ultra Care Option: None
    • Warranty: STANDARD WARRANTY: 1 Year Parts WARRANTY
    • Service: 3 Years FREE Service Plan (INCLUDES LABOR AND LIFETIME TECHNICAL SUPPORT)
    • Rush Service: Standard processing time: ship within 5 to 10 Business Days
    • *_PRICE: (+1827)

    I'll be nice, that junk is 100% over priced at least at the sale price. No one should ever buy it for any use at all.

    the i5 7940X is a skylake X chip that only fits on an X299 MoBo but disables roughly half the boards features. Beyond that 4C/4T CPU's will struggle with many if not most productivty SW compared to equivalent cost CPU's, the AMD counterparts are 6C/12T and that big a difference in processing power will be noticeable and will only get worse as time goes on. Spending over $1800 for a $250 CPU, $250 MoBo and a $500 GPU is just crazy. Even for $1800 on a prebuilt you should get better than that thing.

  • Subtropic PixelSubtropic Pixel Posts: 2,388

    If considering a laptop for rendering, I strongly urge you consider a big gaming laptop with an i9 and nothing less than 32 GB RAM.  These have big fan exhausts and depending on what you buy, sometimes have separate CPU and GPU heatsinks cooled by separate fans.

    My laptop (specs below) actually has two separate power supply cords.  And there's no doubt that it can blow very hotly out the back when it's generating heat.  But it is designed to shunt that heat, well, "away", which is a good thing.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,850
    ebergerly said:

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

    ...and then there is the cooling issue.  You can't slap water cooling on a mobile GPU.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,850
    edited July 2019
    JamesJAB said:
    ebergerly said:

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

     

    You are correct.

    Though it is still dependent on how well the laptop manufacturer designes the cooling setup.  Modern GPUs in laptops will dynamicaly set the clock speed and fan speed based on load and temperature.  Also, you need to look out for mobile GPUs with the MAX-Q designator as these are clocked lower by default for slimmer laptops.

    A modern laptop should never get hot enough to burn out the keyboard or any other componenets (GTX 9x0, 10x0, 16x0 or RTX 20x0)

    Always ensure that your laptop is on a hard flat surface while rendering for optimal air flow into the fans

    Purchase a laptop with a dual fan setup if you plan on using it for rendering

    Honestly when looking ar pre-built computers, there is not much of a price gap between render(gaming) ready desktops and laptops any more.

    Most gaming laptops have a thunderbolt port nowdays.  This is great for adding an external GPU for rendering.

    ...with a notebook, you are still very limited in upgrade options and if any servicing needs to be done, it has to be taken to a technician.  All your cooling is also based on what the system has as there is no room or means for adding aftermarket cooling systems to either the CPU or GPU.  I disagree that one can get a notebook that is comparable to a desktop with the same specs for the same cost.  Gaming does not put the same constant peak load on the GPU (which generates heat) as rendering does.

    Post edited by kyoto kid on
  • TaozTaoz Posts: 10,256
    kyoto kid said:
    JamesJAB said:
    ebergerly said:

    I thought the whole "laptop GPU's perform far worse than desktop GPU's" was an old myth that died (or was supposed to die) years ago when the GTX-10xx series came out.

    A quote from one of the tech sites from a few years ago:

    NVIDIA's new 10-series GPUs, the GTX 1050, GTX 1060, GTX 1070, and GTX 1080, have dropped the 'M' from the end of the number when designed for a laptop. Why? You can expect almost the same performance from both versions.

    For example, both GTX 1080s have 8GB of GDDR5 VRAM and 2560 CUDA cores. The main difference is in the clock speed, where the laptop GTX 1080 comes in just under the desktop version. While performance isn't completely on par with desktop versions, you shouldn't see anything more than about a 5-10% difference."

     

     

    You are correct.

    Though it is still dependent on how well the laptop manufacturer designes the cooling setup.  Modern GPUs in laptops will dynamicaly set the clock speed and fan speed based on load and temperature.  Also, you need to look out for mobile GPUs with the MAX-Q designator as these are clocked lower by default for slimmer laptops.

    A modern laptop should never get hot enough to burn out the keyboard or any other componenets (GTX 9x0, 10x0, 16x0 or RTX 20x0)

    Always ensure that your laptop is on a hard flat surface while rendering for optimal air flow into the fans

    Purchase a laptop with a dual fan setup if you plan on using it for rendering

    Honestly when looking ar pre-built computers, there is not much of a price gap between render(gaming) ready desktops and laptops any more.

    Most gaming laptops have a thunderbolt port nowdays.  This is great for adding an external GPU for rendering.

    ...with a notebook, you are still very limited in upgrade options and if any servicing needs to be done, it has to be taken to a technician.  All your cooling is also based on what the system has as there is no room or means for adding aftermarket cooling systems to wither the CPU or GPU.  I disagree that one can get a notebook that is comparable to a desktop with the same specs for the same cost.  Gaming does not put the same constant peak load on the GPU (which generates heat) as rendering does.

    +1

    Not to mention screen size which IMO is very important when working with 3D, graphics, video, programming etc.. Even for general everyday use I'd never buy anything with a screen size less than 27". Laptops generally have so many limitations compared to desktops that I'd only buy one if I really needed a mobile computer, which is why I've never owned one so far.  

  • ebergerlyebergerly Posts: 3,255
    edited July 2019

    Once you're efectively tethered to a wall outlet to even use the thing why not just build a PC (no one with any technical savvy should ever buy a prebuilt).

    Personally, I think laptops are wonderful. If you go somewhere you can bring all your stuff with you. Like when I go on vacation or on a business trip I just grab my laptop and bring it to the hotel or whatever and pick up where I left off. Or just run downstairs into the living room to futz around on the laptop while watching TV. Can't do that with my desktops. And since I don't spend my entire time rendering in Iray, usually the battery life is fine. For those who are going to college they're indispensable. Sometimes I even head over to the local university and camp out in the food court area with my laptop and have lunch. I don't dislike laptops. And I can certainly understand how for some users they are indispensible. And maybe for them a few more minutes of an Iray render time is pretty much irrelevant. If, in fact, that's the case, which I haven't seen any proof of. 

    As far as prebuilts, and at the risk of being classified as not tech-savvy, I own a prebuilt HP that I've had for years. And it works fine. And assuming that 80-90% of the desktop market is with prebuilts, apparently they're also fine for a lot of other people. Yeah, you may be limited in your upgrade options, but for some that may be somewhat irrelevant. I always maintain a backup computer that mirrors my main computer in case something bad happens, so an older prebuilt is perfect for that. And usually when/if I upgrade one of my other computers the cost is not a whole lot different than buying a whole new PC. New GPU, more RAM, larger case, maybe even a new MB, etc. 

    Different people have different needs, and future upgradability and render times that are 12 seconds faster may not be important. Heck, how many Studio users will even be using Studio in 3-5 years when their PC's get outdated?

    Laptops are fine. They will give you amazingly fast render times (especially compared to what you could get 5-10 years ago). And no, they won't melt if you run Iray. They're designed to stay cool, and Iray doesn't even stress your GPU anywhere near its max ratings in the first place. Just buy a decent brand name and you'll be fine. 

    Post edited by ebergerly on
  • ebergerlyebergerly Posts: 3,255
    edited July 2019
    Taoz said:

    +1

    Not to mention screen size which IMO is very important when working with 3D, graphics, video, programming etc.. Even for general everyday use I'd never buy anything with a screen size less than 27". Laptops generally have so many limitations compared to desktops 

    Actually I've found laptops to be in some ways LESS limiting than desktops. You can always buy a large monitor and plug your laptop in via HDMI or whatever. Works fine.

    And what I do is in order to get some big screen goodness I'll plug my laptop into the big screen TV in the living room. Cuz as we all know, a 43" monitor is much gooder than a 17" inch monitor. More is better. I even do that with my 10+ year old piece of junk Linux laptop with like a 14" screen. I think HDMI goes up to like 50 feet, so you can lie on the sofa with your laptop and relax, rather than sitting at a desk with your desktop. 

    Much nicer than disconnecting and lugging your big ol' desktop downstairs. 

    Post edited by ebergerly on
  • Subtropic PixelSubtropic Pixel Posts: 2,388
    ebergerly said:

    Once you're efectively tethered to a wall outlet to even use the thing why not just build a PC (no one with any technical savvy should ever buy a prebuilt).

    Personally, I think laptops are wonderful. If you go somewhere you can bring all your stuff with you. Like when I go on vacation or on a business trip I just grab my laptop and bring it to the hotel or whatever and pick up where I left off. Or just run downstairs into the living room to futz around on the laptop while watching TV.

    Amen to this!

    ebergerly said:

    Can't do that with my desktops. And since I don't spend my entire time rendering in Iray, usually the battery life is fine. For those who are going to college they're indispensable. Sometimes I even head over to the local university and camp out in the food court area with my laptop and have lunch. I don't dislike laptops. And I can certainly understand how for some users they are indispensible. And maybe for them a few more minutes of an Iray render time is pretty much irrelevant. If, in fact, that's the case, which I haven't seen any proof of. 

    Thank you for speaking truth.

    ebergerly said:

    Different people have different needs, and future upgradability and render times that are 12 seconds faster may not be important. Heck, how many Studio users will even be using Studio in 3-5 years when their PC's get outdated?

    Laptops are fine. They will give you amazingly fast render times (especially compared to what you could get 5-10 years ago). And no, they won't melt if you run Iray. They're designed to stay cool, and Iray doesn't even stress your GPU anywhere near its max ratings in the first place. Just buy a decent brand name and you'll be fine. 

    Thank you.

    ebergerly said:
    Taoz said:

    +1

    Not to mention screen size which IMO is very important when working with 3D, graphics, video, programming etc.. Even for general everyday use I'd never buy anything with a screen size less than 27". Laptops generally have so many limitations compared to desktops 

    Actually I've found laptops to be in some ways LESS limiting than desktops. You can always buy a large monitor and plug your laptop in via HDMI or whatever. Works fine.

    Yep.  I will always have a desktop computer for the "hard stuff", but haha, right now my new i9 laptop is probably more powerful than my 3 year old i7 desktop with its (5-7 year old?) old GTX 980 GPUs.

    Laptops have a place.  Just do yourself a solid and get a competent one.

Sign In or Register to comment.