Monique 7

12467

Comments

  • nelsonsmithnelsonsmith Posts: 1,337
    edited December 2016
    Toyen said:

     

    Nobody complains about stereotypes when blue eyed blondes are wearing traditional Oktoberfest dresses so what's wrong with traditional tribal stuff? : ) 

    Still I think the bundle is well balanced and you can auto-fit older outfit to genesis 3 pretty well most of the time so it doesn't really matter : )

    I'm taking that as being facetious, though there are probably a lot of people that might take it seriously.   The problem with sterotypes of groups that we don't get a lot of is the fact that the stereotype is ALL we get when we see them.  I know a lot of native Americans and very seldom do I see them in traditional garb except at pow wows, but I can guarantee that nearly 90% of the time when I see a native American depicted in art it's going to be set in what appears to be the 1800s.

    There are plenty of depictions of blue-eyed blondes that aren't stereotypical so the occasional Valkyrie, or milk maid doesn't really come off as egregious.  Stereotypes really don't have much to do with being or not being PC.  It's just that people are tired of a lot of stuff.   At worst it simply shows a dearth of imagination.

    Post edited by nelsonsmith on
  • FSMCDesignsFSMCDesigns Posts: 12,842
    edited December 2016

    Well I finally got her installed and what a great skin texture, better than I expected. For someone that doesn't normally purchase addon characters i am up to five now for genesis 3, that is very unprecedented for me, LOL

    Quick render to test the skin texture (figure shape is mine)

     

    skintest.jpg
    939 x 870 - 831K
    Post edited by FSMCDesigns on
  • Toyen said:

    Yeah they could have included at least one african/"stereotypical" themed outfit with Monique.

    Nobody complains about stereotypes when blue eyed blondes are wearing traditional Oktoberfest dresses so what's wrong with traditional tribal stuff? : ) 

     

    The problem is that a lot of Caucasian (and Asian) stereotypical characters are often portrayed neutral or heroic while witch doctor imagery was pretty much always portrayed in the negative.  "Backwards savage" and many other impolite conotations.  About the only such portrayal that's positive is Egyptians but Hollywood aggressively does everything possible to pretend Egypt isn't in Africa (and Ancient Egypt had a slightly different ethnic makeup than modern Egypt anyways).  Voodoo winds up weird since there ARE modern heroic portrayals...but it usually gets mixed in with witch evil doctors.  Though with that said, the actual voodoo bundle for Genesis 2 is better realized than Monique 6's Pro Bundle.  Also there were many, even a few of the Daz reps who post in the forums, who noted that the promo/advertisement setup for Monique and Darius 6 was poor even outside of the contents.

    Now, an interesting thing is the lack of genuine African tribal and modern wear.  In other words, Oktoberfest equivalents mostly don't exist.  This discussion might be better over in the Black is Beautiful thread than bogging this one down.

     

  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,085

    I'd also point out that when you look at Michael or Victoria or Olympia pro bundles, you aren't seeing 'stereotypically Caucasian' stuff.

    And if you're immediate reaction is 'well, no, they have _normal_ stuff' then bingo, there's the problem right there.

     

  • jag11jag11 Posts: 885

    I remember, 4 months or so after Monique 6 came out, Victoria 7 was introduced, maybe Victoria 8 in March Madness? 

    Nice character, btw.

  • jag11 said:

    I remember, 4 months or so after Monique 6 came out, Victoria 7 was introduced, maybe Victoria 8 in March Madness? 

    Nice character, btw.

    Please... NO!!!

    Not 8, not 8, not8...

    Not yet. crying

  • ToyenToyen Posts: 2,029

    Monique 6 had 2/3 "stereotypical" outfits while Dairus 6 had 1/3. Monique could have had 1 as well but still, it's not a catastrophe to me. Keep in mind that characters of color ar the best chance how to sell and advertise these.
    Imagine how silly would a voodo african witch doctor/samurai look on a white girl. Not to mention there would definitely be someone accusing creators of culture appropriation instead of stereotypes :D

    It's damned if you do damned if you don't.

    I'm still hoping for a Native American couple and if I were a creator, of course I'd dress them up in traditional garb for the main promo even though most natives do not dress like that these days of course.

    Why? Simply because it's more eye catching, more unique and basically the only chance to show off and sell that outfit.  

    I think the problem would be solved if we got more than one black/asian couple per generation thus the content would spread out and the bundles were less likely to fall entirely to stereotype but I doubt this will happen :(

    But maybe Daz will surprise us this time around : )

    And yeah of course Vicky and Michael aren't being stereotyped, they're always kinda basic and themeless.

    jak11 I hope you are wrong! 2017 must belong to Genesis 3 :(

  • nelsonsmithnelsonsmith Posts: 1,337
    edited December 2016
    Toyen said:


    Imagine how silly would a voodo african witch doctor/samurai look on a white girl. Not to mention there would definitely be someone accusing creators of culture appropriation instead of stereotypes :D

    Silly, but you still see it.  What was the Bride in  'Kill Bill' after all?  And I see white girls in Native American head dresses all the time in photography even though the image is incorrect on several fronts, appropriation being the least of it.   Thing is You've had black Soldiers in every war the US has ever fought,  there were black cowboys (quite a few actually),  the majority of pirates believe it or not were not Causcasian.  You have the Moors, and the list goes on. The clothes for any of those would sell like hotcakes regardless of the character they happened to be attached to.  You don't have to resort to stereotypes to sell black characters.    It doesn't have to be a "damned if you do damned if you don't" situation if you just put a modicum of thought into it.   So until I see a Aryan character with a Nazi theme, or the next Giovanni comes out with a Mafia theme being showcased, I'm calling Foul and BS on the stereotyping of ethnic characters.  There comes a time when you need to simply stop indulging people in their ignorance.

    Post edited by nelsonsmith on
  • ChoholeChohole Posts: 33,604

    So until I see a Aryan character with a Nazi theme

    That would actually be against the law in some parts of Europe.

  • dreamfarmerdreamfarmer Posts: 2,128

    DE Nadira, with some  postwork adjustments. De-aged to 'older teen'. I really do love the costume. I saw lots of people saying 'blah another woodland outfit' but I'm delighted to see non-skimpwear fantasy stuff that isn't full metal armor. Though I guess much of that is made by Bobbie25?

  • nelsonsmithnelsonsmith Posts: 1,337
    Chohole said:

    So until I see a Aryan character with a Nazi theme

    That would actually be against the law in some parts of Europe.

    And I guess some people would consider that PC taken to an extreme as well.

  • Monique is currently not wearing her new item discount.

  • nemesis10nemesis10 Posts: 3,756
    edited December 2016

    I suddenly feel this urge to do a render of Dido Elizabeth Belle if I can figure out what clothes for her...  

    Post edited by nemesis10 on
  • j cadej cade Posts: 2,310
    Toyen said:


    Imagine how silly would a voodo african witch doctor/samurai look on a white girl. Not to mention there would definitely be someone accusing creators of culture appropriation instead of stereotypes :D

    Silly, but you still see it.  What was the Bride in  'Kill Bill' after all?  And I see white girls in Native American head dresses all the time in photography even though the image is incorrect on several fronts, appropriation being the least of it.   Thing is You've had black Soldiers in every war the US has ever fought,  there were black cowboys (quite a few actually),  the majority of pirates believe it or not were not Causcasian.  You have the Moors, and the list goes on. The clothes for any of those would sell like hotcakes regardless of the character they happened to be attached to.  You don't have to resort to stereotypes to sell black characters.    It doesn't have to be a "damned if you do damned if you don't" situation if you just put a modicum of thought into it.   So until I see a Aryan character with a Nazi theme, or the next Giovanni comes out with a Mafia theme being showcased, I'm calling Foul and BS on the stereotyping of ethnic characters.  There comes a time when you need to simply stop indulging people in their ignorance.

    Ivan came with a mobster outfit. "Russian Mobster" is definitely a stereotype.

    Not staking a claim on bad or good or whatever,

  • Toyen said:

    I think the problem would be solved if we got more than one black/asian couple per generation thus the content would spread out and the bundles were less likely to fall entirely to stereotype but I doubt this will happen :(

    Admittedly, that is the main problem. From when I last checked, there's less than 10 total black males for Genesis 3 and that was both Daz and Renderosity combined.

  • cherpenbeckcherpenbeck Posts: 1,416

    And Monique is still not wearing her new item discount. Waiting ...

  • AllenArtAllenArt Posts: 7,175
    edited December 2016

    I hope Raiya does head morph packs for the G3 characters too :). 

    While I try to be respectful of other people's feelings, I'm very un-PC. I feel that PC gone crazy means the end of free speech. Having said that, I still hate some of the names for black or characters of color like Jasmine or Sapphire. Urgh. I went to school with Paula, Lisa, Leslie, etc....no reason a black female can't be named one of those ;). *shakes head* LOL. And to be honest, the voodoo stuff was a little over the top. Glad we have it tho. Just wish it could have been marketed a little differently ;).

    Laurie

    Post edited by AllenArt on
  • Ron KnightsRon Knights Posts: 2,031

    At one time, I lived in Minneapolis, MN, right near the Indian Nation, a large apartment community of Native Americans. We had a large number of Native Americans in the general "downtown, or in-town" community. I assure you, none of them wore "Native American" costumes, unless they participated in one of the many Native American celebrations. 

    North Minneapolis is where the largest percentage of Arican Americans (blacks?!) live. I worked for several months as a Security Officer in that neighborhood. I never saw a single person dressed in a Voodoo outfit, or gogo outfit for that matter.

    I prefer to work in the "Real World" with my cartoon characters. Marlin & friends wear everyday clothes. I prefer to avoid dresses on women just because dresses can be a logistical problem when posing characters. All too often I find only a small number of outfits for my characters to wear.

  • nelsonsmithnelsonsmith Posts: 1,337
    edited December 2016

     

     I prefer to avoid dresses on women just because dresses can be a logistical problem when posing characters. All too often I find only a small number of outfits for my characters to wear.

    You can say that again.  It's amazing how many dresses aren't made to do simple everyday things such as sitting down, or even kneeling without doing an amazing amount of tweaking and morphing to get it to look natural.  Try to make a character do anything beside pose standing up and you start to understand why there's so much skimp wear in the Daz catalog.

    Post edited by nelsonsmith on
  • Oso3DOso3D Posts: 15,085

    God, yes. 90% of the reason I use things like VWD is flipping dresses and skirts looking terrible.

  • 3Diva3Diva Posts: 11,970
    edited December 2016

    The problem is more--what if blue-eyed blondes ONLY appeared wearing Oktoberfest dresses? I'm hoping now that there's a Feature black woman for Genesis3 we'll see a lot more dark skin in promos.

    I agree. Considering we only get ONE official "7" figure that is a black woman, they need to stay clear of stereotypes. It would be a different story if we had a more equal representation of characters of different races. But since we've gotten TWENTY THREE white "7 figures" so far and only ONE black character, there doesn't need be any stereotypes attached to the ONE black character's bundle. 

    Post edited by 3Diva on
  • RCDescheneRCDeschene Posts: 2,816

    The problem is more--what if blue-eyed blondes ONLY appeared wearing Oktoberfest dresses? I'm hoping now that there's a Feature black woman for Genesis3 we'll see a lot more dark skin in promos.

    I agree. Considering we only get ONE official "7" figure that is a black woman, they need to stay clear of stereotypes. It would be a different story if we had a more equal representation of characters of different races. But since we've gotten TWENTY THREE white "7 figures" so far and only ONE black character, there doesn't need be any stereotypes attached to the ONE black character's bundle. 

    What about Kalea and Kimo? Polynisian isn't exactly known for looking ghostly pale.

  • 3Diva3Diva Posts: 11,970

    The problem is more--what if blue-eyed blondes ONLY appeared wearing Oktoberfest dresses? I'm hoping now that there's a Feature black woman for Genesis3 we'll see a lot more dark skin in promos.

    I agree. Considering we only get ONE official "7" figure that is a black woman, they need to stay clear of stereotypes. It would be a different story if we had a more equal representation of characters of different races. But since we've gotten TWENTY THREE white "7 figures" so far and only ONE black character, there doesn't need be any stereotypes attached to the ONE black character's bundle. 

    What about Kalea and Kimo? Polynisian isn't exactly known for looking ghostly pale.

    I'm not sure what your point is. I didn't count Kalea, Kimo, Lee, or Mei Lin as part of the 23 - as I only counted the white figures. 

    Lucian
    Lilith 
    Sunny 
    Tween Ryan 
    Tween Julie 
    Kenji 
    Aiko 
    Ivan 
    Rune 
    Izabella 
    Guy 
    Girl 
    Gianni 
    Gia

    Leo
    Olympia 
    Michael 
    Arabella 
    Teen Josie 
    Karen 
    Bethany 
    Eva 
    Victoria 

    To be fair there are a couple of characters, like Sunny, who's ethnicity is a bit less clear, but for the most part the VAST majority of them are white. 

     

     

     

  • nemesis10nemesis10 Posts: 3,756

    The problem is more--what if blue-eyed blondes ONLY appeared wearing Oktoberfest dresses? I'm hoping now that there's a Feature black woman for Genesis3 we'll see a lot more dark skin in promos.

    I agree. Considering we only get ONE official "7" figure that is a black woman, they need to stay clear of stereotypes. It would be a different story if we had a more equal representation of characters of different races. But since we've gotten TWENTY THREE white "7 figures" so far and only ONE black character, there doesn't need be any stereotypes attached to the ONE black character's bundle. 

    What about Kalea and Kimo? Polynisian isn't exactly known for looking ghostly pale.

    I think Kalea and Kimo are examples where the garments are either ethnically appropriate island beach wear, fantasy island outfits which aren't cartoon or negative, or versitle clothes that anyone could wear,  As far as I could see, not a criminal, skank, or cartoon in sight....  Only, Kimo got an outfit that wasn't 20th century...  but he did get an apocolyptic garment...  Asian representation in the store is also troubling as the representation of black people so Klea and Kimo were a step  forward in not presenting the demure and exotic geisha or the Bruce Lee clone.  Monique seems a great step forward in changing things.  "Polynisian isn't exactly known for looking ghostly pale." but they aren't black.

  • I'm not sure what your point is. I didn't count Kalea, Kimo, Lee, or Mei Lin as part of the 23 - as I only counted the white figures. 

    Lucian
    Lilith 
    Sunny 
    Tween Ryan 
    Tween Julie 
    Kenji 
    Aiko 
    Ivan 
    Rune 
    Izabella 
    Guy 
    Girl 
    Gianni 
    Gia

    Leo
    Olympia 
    Michael 
    Arabella 
    Teen Josie 
    Karen 
    Bethany 
    Eva 
    Victoria 

    To be fair there are a couple of characters, like Sunny, who's ethnicity is a bit less clear, but for the most part the VAST majority of them are white. 

    While quite fair skinned, Kenji and Aiko are both Asian. It's just that they're going for an anime videogame aesthetic.

  • RedzRedz Posts: 1,459
    edited December 2016

    Finally got the chance to do a test render of Monique 7. I think she's beautiful and very realistic. My only tiny quibble - I'm not sure how I feel about including ear piercings as part of the base textures. I've seen it now on a couple of the base characters. While it might be good for realism (provided earrings load to match the texture), piercing holes may not suit all renders. What do you think?

    ETA: added a pic of the ear piercing

    monique7_01.png
    909 x 1000 - 1021K
    monique7_earring.png
    909 x 1000 - 1M
    Post edited by Redz on
  • ToyenToyen Posts: 2,029

    Amazing render Redz!

    About the ear piercing, it should be easy to simply change the position of the earring to fit the texture by moving it and/or scaling a bit.

     

  • RedzRedz Posts: 1,459

    Finally got the chance to do a test render of Monique 7. I think she's beautiful and very realistic. My only tiny quibble - I'm not sure how I feel about including ear piercings as part of the base textures. I've seen it now on a couple of the base characters. While it might be good for realism (provided earrings load to match the texture), piercing holes may not suit all renders. What do you think?

    Toyen said:

    Amazing render Redz!

    About the ear piercing, it should be easy to simply change the position of the earring to fit the texture by moving it and/or scaling a bit.

     

    Thanks Toyen. I've found it's not so easy -conforming earrings won't budge unless they have included morphs. I can unfit and parent them to reposition them manually, but these ones, for example, are paired, so when they need to be x-translated (as they do to fit Monique's piercing holes), one moves the right way and the other doesn't. So I'd have to unpair them or load a second pair and hide geometry. Suddenly it starts to seem like a lot of work for a small detail. LOL

  • FistyFisty Posts: 3,416
    Redz said:

    Finally got the chance to do a test render of Monique 7. I think she's beautiful and very realistic. My only tiny quibble - I'm not sure how I feel about including ear piercings as part of the base textures. I've seen it now on a couple of the base characters. While it might be good for realism (provided earrings load to match the texture), piercing holes may not suit all renders. What do you think?

    ETA: added a pic of the ear piercing

    Just grab that ring in the viewport with the universal manipulator and move it..  I don't go through the trouble of adding extra bones to my earring for noithing.  cheeky

  • RedzRedz Posts: 1,459
    Fisty said:
    Redz said:

    Finally got the chance to do a test render of Monique 7. I think she's beautiful and very realistic. My only tiny quibble - I'm not sure how I feel about including ear piercings as part of the base textures. I've seen it now on a couple of the base characters. While it might be good for realism (provided earrings load to match the texture), piercing holes may not suit all renders. What do you think?

    ETA: added a pic of the ear piercing

    Just grab that ring in the viewport with the universal manipulator and move it..  I don't go through the trouble of adding extra bones to my earring for noithing.  cheeky

    Aha! That is great to know. I love picking up new knowledge. Thanks Fisty. 

Sign In or Register to comment.