Loading...
> >

Which image do you prefer "Anger, Love and Mayhem in the Neighborhood"

kenmokenmo Posts: 1,233
edited February 24 in Art Studio

Which image do you prefer 

With speech balloons 

 

 

Love, Anger and Mayhem in the Neighborhood {2026}=KRM02.jpg
2999 x 1948 - 2M
Post edited by kenmo on

Comments

  • kenmokenmo Posts: 1,233

    OR "NO speech balloons"

     

     

     

    Love, Anger and Mayhem in the Neighborhood no speech {2026}=KRM02.jpg
    2000 x 1299 - 789K
  • SofaCitizenSofaCitizen Posts: 2,185

    My vote would be for the image without speech balloons.

    My reasoning is that I think it is preferable to allow the viewer to spot the story/stories/easter-eggs within the image themselves as they look at it, rather than having things more "pointed out".

  • kenmokenmo Posts: 1,233

    SofaCitizen said:

    My vote would be for the image without speech balloons.

    My reasoning is that I think it is preferable to allow the viewer to spot the story/stories/easter-eggs within the image themselves as they look at it, rather than having things more "pointed out".

    Thanks kindly for the reply, I truly appreciate your opinion... 

  • richardandtracyrichardandtracy Posts: 8,020

    I honestly don't know.

    I think a couple of stories (eg ring bottom left) benefit from the balloons, but bottom right, I don't think they add anything. So.. both are better in places. Not very helpful, I know.Though my feeling is that the ballooned one is closer to being right.

    Regards,

    Richard

  • kenmokenmo Posts: 1,233

    richardandtracy said:

    I honestly don't know.

    I think a couple of stories (eg ring bottom left) benefit from the balloons, but bottom right, I don't think they add anything. So.. both are better in places. Not very helpful, I know.Though my feeling is that the ballooned one is closer to being right.

    Regards,

    Richard

    Thank you... 

  • 3DIO3DIO Posts: 620
    edited April 25

    It's fun to imagine what they're saying to each other, and interesting to see what they actually said, so personally I think they work best as a pair!

     

    Post edited by 3DIO on
  • 3Diva3Diva Posts: 12,058

    I've been a comic book fan for many years, so I'm a fan of speech bubbles, but having said that, I prefer the image without. There is so much going on in the scene, allowing the viewer to decide for themselves what's going on is a lot more engaging. The human mind is so creative and comes up with even more fun stories than you may have even intended. Allowing the viewer to interpret the scenarios is powerful too, as it helps the viewer engage more with the art. 

    Nicely done by the way, it must have taken ages to set up that scene! SO MANY characters and so much going on in one shot. The patience it must have taken to set all that up. That's impressive!

  • 3Diva3Diva Posts: 12,058

    I can't help but wonder what time period the image represents. Probably not today, everyone's faces would be stuck to their phones and not paying attention to anything else around them. lol

    I do miss the days when people actually interacted with each other rather than mainly interacting with the screens in front of their faces.

Sign In or Register to comment.