Character age guessing with How-old.net

deepred6502deepred6502 Posts: 389
edited September 2018 in The Commons

Just for curiosity, I put a few characters (mostly ones I've purchased) through Microsoft's How-old.net filter. Here are the results, many of which I'd take with a grain of salt as there can be wildly different results with the same character, and Microsoft admits it's still a work in progress.

For example, Cara by DTHUREGIF is meant to be 18 but the How-old engine thinks she's anything between 6 and 20; Liv for V4 by the same artist is supposedly 35-42 but a bit under. Mage by Vyktohria is recognisably a "crone" but How-old was way under; by contrast, Nalfaar by the same artist is about right.

Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.49.55.png
1366 x 768 - 449K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 21.52.32.png
1366 x 768 - 920K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 21.55.28.png
1366 x 768 - 678K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 22.22.48.png
1366 x 768 - 408K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 22.30.59.png
1366 x 768 - 426K
Screenshot 2018-08-24 at 00.33.07.png
1366 x 768 - 667K
Opera Snapshot_2018-08-22_230354_how-old.net.png
940 x 1030 - 1M
Opera Snapshot_2018-08-22_230457_how-old.net.png
940 x 701 - 651K
Opera Snapshot_2018-08-22_230700_how-old.net.png
940 x 696 - 171K
Opera Snapshot_2018-08-22_230751_how-old.net.png
940 x 868 - 500K
Opera Snapshot_2018-08-22_225506_how-old.net.png
1865 x 943 - 944K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.33.03.png
910 x 675 - 499K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.34.57.png
910 x 675 - 369K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.36.31.png
910 x 675 - 563K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.38.29.png
910 x 673 - 721K
Screenshot 2018-08-22 at 18.39.52.png
910 x 676 - 698K
Post edited by deepred6502 on

Comments

  • It seems to rely significantly on the skin clarity, moreso than merely the proportions or such tells as bags and jowls.  The one it pegs as 27 would be AT LEAST 20-25 years older to my eyes.

  • It seems to rely significantly on the skin clarity, moreso than merely the proportions or such tells as bags and jowls.  The one it pegs as 27 would be AT LEAST 20-25 years older to my eyes.

    i think also How-old.net only scans faces, not other body proportions like breast/waist/hip proportions, so it'll estimate a lot younger with many pics.

  • It appears to be only slightly worse than just assigning random numbers out of a hat :P

  • LinwellyLinwelly Posts: 6,054

    For those three sisters I would say the google estimate is more accuate than the age written above, just looking at their faces. Some other results are rather funny. I guess I#ll try with some of my own characters as well :D

  • Serene NightSerene Night Posts: 17,704
    edited August 2018

    It seems pretty accurate for the guys. It consistently pegs Owen as being Older than Boyd, which is true his body is older.  Although one time it pegged him as 41. I think it interprets facial hair as being older.

    27-2.JPG
    777 x 567 - 56K
    Post edited by Serene Night on
  • RawArtRawArt Posts: 6,065
    edited August 2018

    Ok..that was kinda fun

    ages.jpg
    1892 x 500 - 320K
    Post edited by RawArt on
  • RawArt said:

    Ok..that was kinda fun

    Ah, so your catalogue is an exercise in senior abuse?

  • RawArtRawArt Posts: 6,065
    RawArt said:

    Ok..that was kinda fun

    Ah, so your catalogue is an exercise in senior abuse?

    Abuse?.....I treat my old friends well.................   (though now that you mention it, one has scars all over, the other comes with bruises and bullet wounds, and the orc has a broken tusk....and yeah...guess I did that to them.....damn...I am mean) :P

     

  • ColinFrenchColinFrench Posts: 649
    edited August 2018

    Ah-hah! I always thought orcs had a longer lifespan than humans! laugh

    Post edited by ColinFrench on
  • RawArtRawArt Posts: 6,065

    Ah-hah! I always thought orcs had a longer lifespan than humans! laugh

    Right?......now we have proof ;)

  • It appears to be focusing on the eye spread, and their relation to the nose and mouth. Hence, the old lady with defined bags under her eyes reads as being in her 20s, simply because the distance between her eyes, nose, and mouth are that of a younger woman. Same with the 20-somethings showing as being 9 and 6.

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,722

    It really is more difficult than it used to be with most people not working in farming and other outdoor jobs anymore. And then when you factor in things like premature greying, premature balding, and obesity epidemics and the tell-tale signs go out the window now more than ever and we are left with relying on stereotypes...well there is a good reason way they say never guess a women's age. 

  • Yeah, I totally needed another thing to distract me... XD

Sign In or Register to comment.