Computer failure. Solved. Now playing with 1070 ti!

135

Comments

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    Well 336 Cuda cores is better than no Cuda cores I guess.  The GTX 460 is apparently part of the Fermi family. I'm seeing a 768 MB version and a 1 GB version in this review.  1 GB will drive the monitor and Daz Studio viewport at least, but I'm guessing it won't be very helpful for most renders...

    https://www.anandtech.com/show/3809/nvidias-geforce-gtx-460-the-200-king/4

    2010 really wasn't all that long ago, except in computer hardware timeframes.  As the CPU you have is also older, while the drivers may no longer being updated, you should still be able to find some that will play nice with your system.

    As long as you have the right power connectors, I don't see any reason why the GTX 460 shouldn't fit inside your system.

    Lol, I know. 336 cuda cores, surprise. Most likely, ill plug it in, confirm that the initial failure was a video card issue, and then... probably take it out and plug it back into the old xp computer. Ill get a new card in a couple months or whenever the price drop hits. Until then, im thinking that a break from daz wouldnt be such a bad thing. Ill still probably shop if the prices are right, but a small pause might just help with this creative wall that ive been smacking my head against for awhile.laugh

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    Update:

    So I tried running the Area 51 on my old gtx 460 and it scoffed at the mere mention of the thought. What was interesting about that expirement was that I heard a distinct 6 Beep repeating alarm coming from the computer indicating a bad card. Now that I have clearly heard what one of those alarms sounds like, I can say without a doubt that there is NO alarm associated with my gtx 770, the one im having issues with. So I am currently in safe mode with networking ande installing the lates nvidea driver. The driver just finished installing. Im now going to restart the computer...

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    No change.

    I think im just going to have to call a shop.crying

  • ebergerlyebergerly Posts: 3,255
    edited June 2018

    Another thing to consider is that sometimes you need to completely remove NVIDIA drivers before installing new ones or your issues don't go away. And I mean COMPLETELY. When I did it last year (?) I needed to download a non-NVIDIA application (recommended by all the smart folks in the NVIDIA forums) that caused my virus software to go nuts. 

    It was a pain, it took a long time, but finally it worked. I believe this was after I installed a new 1080ti in the slot next to an old card (forget the model) and it caused havoc. 

    Don't ask me why NIVIDIA can't make their own app that removes drivers completely. 

    EDIT: Oh, it was called "DDU". Display Driver Uninstaller. 

    Post edited by ebergerly on
  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    Odd that a known good card is being read as bad in the machine. Are you able to hook your 770 into the xp machine? If you can and if it works, then there is something else wrong with your area 51 machine.

  • nonesuch00nonesuch00 Posts: 18,723
    edited June 2018

    The card is probably good as far as computational circuitry but maybe the memory has gone bad although maybe not, you'd think the card would give out some diagnosis error. The fact that the card is working in VGA mode where it uses much less memory might be hinting at such a problem.

    Search for an nVidia utility that tests an nVidia card's memory or other circuitry independant of whether it is using nVidia drivers (or yours is using the failsafe VGA drivers in Safemode).

    Post edited by nonesuch00 on
  • tj_1ca9500btj_1ca9500b Posts: 2,057

    Quick questions.

    Now that you've cracked your case open, do you have more than one PCIe 16 slot?  If so, did you try plugging in your GTX 460 into the second slot, while leaving the other card plugged into the first slot?

    Also, have you been able to figure out how to get into your BIOS screen?

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,851

    Well 336 Cuda cores is better than no Cuda cores I guess.  The GTX 460 is apparently part of the Fermi family. I'm seeing a 768 MB version and a 1 GB version in this review.  1 GB will drive the monitor and Daz Studio viewport at least, but I'm guessing it won't be very helpful for most renders...

    https://www.anandtech.com/show/3809/nvidias-geforce-gtx-460-the-200-king/4

    2010 really wasn't all that long ago, except in computer hardware timeframes.  As the CPU you have is also older, while the drivers may no longer being updated, you should still be able to find some that will play nice with your system.

    As long as you have the right power connectors, I don't see any reason why the GTX 460 shouldn't fit inside your system.

    ...1 GB is pretty useless for rendering (I have the same card).  Good as a secondary card to run the displays when dedicating a more powerful one to just rendering, but that's about it.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    Odd that a known good card is being read as bad in the machine. Are you able to hook your 770 into the xp machine? If you can and if it works, then there is something else wrong with your area 51 machine.

    That thought crossed my mind. Im not sure it will fit but I can take a look at it.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    Quick questions.

    Now that you've cracked your case open, do you have more than one PCIe 16 slot?  If so, did you try plugging in your GTX 460 into the second slot, while leaving the other card plugged into the first slot?

    Also, have you been able to figure out how to get into your BIOS screen?

    I have 3 slots. Ill need to check and see if my psu can compensate for two cards. Its an 850 watt psu. I can get into the bios screen.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    My trusty gtx 770 has given up the ghost!

    I finally broke down and took it into a shop. Super glad that I did as well, I found an excellent guy! We ended up gabbing for an hour when I took the thing in. He was able to determine that it was the card, and cleaned up my computer. Even said I could take an old ATI card that he had for free (refused it though as I will be wanting nvidea for iray). All for the reasonable price of just 75 bucks! Quite a find.

    So now, the search begins for a new card.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,851

    ...good you finally found the cause.

    Fortunately card prices are coming back down to earth.  The Nvidia store has the 1070 (399$) reference editions available at their base cost, and it looks like the 1080 Ti is back in stock for 699$.  Not sure if the 1060 for 299$ is the 3 or 6 GB one.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727
    kyoto kid said:

    ...good you finally found the cause.

    Fortunately card prices are coming back down to earth.  The Nvidia store has the 1070 (399$) reference editions available at their base cost, and it looks like the 1080 Ti is back in stock for 699$.  Not sure if the 1060 for 299$ is the 3 or 6 GB one.

    Yah, im feeling somewhat more positive about card prices these days. Ill be trying to stretch that dollar as far as I can.laugh

  • frank0314frank0314 Posts: 14,708

    No you won't be able to use it for Iray. Iray requires 4gb VRAM

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,851
    edited June 2018

    ...depending on your budget a 6 GB 1060 would be OK as long as you don't intend to render huge scenes.  Based on the prices I saw at Newegg I would think the one in the Nvida store is the 6 GB model (Newegg running from 289$ for one of the single fan "mini" cards to around 349$ for the dual fan ones)

    A 1070 will give you a little more overhead but you probably would be better off with going direct to Nvidia as the lowest price at Newegg I saw was 409$ and many are still hovering around the 500$ mark.

    Since you are running 8.1 you should be able to use pretty much all the VRAM your card has.

    Post edited by kyoto kid on
  • frank0314frank0314 Posts: 14,708

    My wife has the GTX 980Ti 6GB and it works great in Iray and DS.

  • AllenArtAllenArt Posts: 7,175

    I have a GTX 980Ti too...runs fine with Iray.

    Laurie

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    Im hopeing to keep costs under 500 bones and im assuming that I will need another psu, but we shall see.

    Im sure that any card that I get is going to blow my mind as far as speed comparisons (with the 770) are concerned.

  • outrider42outrider42 Posts: 3,679

    I thought Iray had dropped support for Fermi cards, so that 460 wouldn't work anyway.

    I don't know what your budget is, but personally I think the 1070ti is a very solid buy. According to benchmarks I have seen it out performs the 1080 at Iray. So for about $40 or $50 more than the base 1070, you can get a nice Iray performance upgrade along with 8GB VRAM.

    I'm not going to tell you what to buy, but I really like that EVGA offers extended warranties on their cards for a pretty small price. You can buy the card anywhere, when you register it within 90 days of purchase, you can buy either a 5 year or 10 (!) year warranty for the card. To be clear, these add either 2 or 7 years to the 3 year factory warranty that most cards come with. The price of these scale on the MSRP of the card, but they cap at $30 and $60 respectievly. So for a max $60 you can have a 10 YEAR warranty on your GPU. It gets better, because you can transfer this warranty if you sell the card. That means you can get more money if you sell the card. Think about all the 5 year old cards you see on ebay, it is pretty rare to see one say they have a warranty. It would be incredible to to be able to buy an old card that still has warranty on it. And if you had bought such a warranty on the 770, it would still have about 4 years left on its warranty! That's pretty tough deal to beat. Sometimes when people return dead GPUs they even get a better one in return, like say they get the next generation x70, which would be a 970 in this case.

    Though I have bought all my GPUs used because I have been a poor boy. And as such I have never been shy to suggest buying used if the price is right because you really can save a lot in some cases. Next time I plan on buying new.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,851

    ...indeed, that is how I ended up with my Titan X. The last "new" card I bought was my old 460 when I built my system. I was saving for a 1070 just before the prices shot into the stratosphere.

    Sadly most EVGA 1070s and 1070 Ti's I am seeing at Newegg are still over 500$. There are a couple Ti's for about 490$ but some reviews issues with the cooling fans and no backplate.

    There is one 1070 Hybrid liquid cooled card for 489$

    https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814487264

    Also comes with a free 550w PSU that could serve as a backup or auxiliary.

  • tj_1ca9500btj_1ca9500b Posts: 2,057

    While I'm sad that your card is dead, I'm glad that you sorted things out.  I bet you are looking forward to getting a newer graphics card though!

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    While I'm sad that your card is dead, I'm glad that you sorted things out.  I bet you are looking forward to getting a newer graphics card though!

    Oh yah! I was incredibly mopey for several days after the card died. Looking forward to rendering with some new power!

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    I thought Iray had dropped support for Fermi cards, so that 460 wouldn't work anyway.

    I don't know what your budget is, but personally I think the 1070ti is a very solid buy. According to benchmarks I have seen it out performs the 1080 at Iray. So for about $40 or $50 more than the base 1070, you can get a nice Iray performance upgrade along with 8GB VRAM.

    I'm not going to tell you what to buy, but I really like that EVGA offers extended warranties on their cards for a pretty small price. You can buy the card anywhere, when you register it within 90 days of purchase, you can buy either a 5 year or 10 (!) year warranty for the card. To be clear, these add either 2 or 7 years to the 3 year factory warranty that most cards come with. The price of these scale on the MSRP of the card, but they cap at $30 and $60 respectievly. So for a max $60 you can have a 10 YEAR warranty on your GPU. It gets better, because you can transfer this warranty if you sell the card. That means you can get more money if you sell the card. Think about all the 5 year old cards you see on ebay, it is pretty rare to see one say they have a warranty. It would be incredible to to be able to buy an old card that still has warranty on it. And if you had bought such a warranty on the 770, it would still have about 4 years left on its warranty! That's pretty tough deal to beat. Sometimes when people return dead GPUs they even get a better one in return, like say they get the next generation x70, which would be a 970 in this case.

    Though I have bought all my GPUs used because I have been a poor boy. And as such I have never been shy to suggest buying used if the price is right because you really can save a lot in some cases. Next time I plan on buying new.

    A 10 year warranty would be really nice. Standard is probably just 90 days isnt it?

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727
    kyoto kid said:

    ...indeed, that is how I ended up with my Titan X. The last "new" card I bought was my old 460 when I built my system. I was saving for a 1070 just before the prices shot into the stratosphere.

    Sadly most EVGA 1070s and 1070 Ti's I am seeing at Newegg are still over 500$. There are a couple Ti's for about 490$ but some reviews issues with the cooling fans and no backplate.

    There is one 1070 Hybrid liquid cooled card for 489$

    https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814487264

    Also comes with a free 550w PSU that could serve as a backup or auxiliary.

    I know absolutely nothing about liquid cooled cards. Do you have to do anything to maintain them at all?

  • kaotkblisskaotkbliss Posts: 2,914

    If only I had an extra $500. Not concerned about the power supply as I have a pretty good one, but that looks like a pretty good deal of the hybrid card.

    Only thing that bugs me is the water lines are coming out past the side of the fan that I would think is supposed to attatch to the PC case, so they would get in the way.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727

    So what is the difference between a card and its "TI" version? What is this ti of which we speak?

    Im think that a 1070 might be an option. Just digging for more details.

  • kyoto kidkyoto kid Posts: 41,851

    ..the 1070 Ti has more cores and is supposedly faster but has the same VRAM as the standard 1070. Usually a Ti also has increased VRAM (like the 1080 Ti).

    I have never used a water cooled GPU or CPU (when I built my system it was still pretty exotic, and much more expensive). The one thing I do know is it helps the card of CPU to run cooler at peak use than standard air cooling.

  • hphoenixhphoenix Posts: 1,335
    kyoto kid said:

    ...indeed, that is how I ended up with my Titan X. The last "new" card I bought was my old 460 when I built my system. I was saving for a 1070 just before the prices shot into the stratosphere.

    Sadly most EVGA 1070s and 1070 Ti's I am seeing at Newegg are still over 500$. There are a couple Ti's for about 490$ but some reviews issues with the cooling fans and no backplate.

    There is one 1070 Hybrid liquid cooled card for 489$

    https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814487264

    Also comes with a free 550w PSU that could serve as a backup or auxiliary.

    I know absolutely nothing about liquid cooled cards. Do you have to do anything to maintain them at all?

    Just clicked the link, it's listing at $580.  It's a closed-loop water cooling solution, so no maintainence issues.  Just blow out the radiator/fan combo with compressed air every so often (like all fans).

     

    So what is the difference between a card and its "TI" version? What is this ti of which we speak?

    Im think that a 1070 might be an option. Just digging for more details.

    The "TI" suffix was added by a card manufacturer way back in Earlier GeForce days, it was an abbreviation for "Titanium", which meant it was a better spec GPU (usually meant it could be overclocked better, and was overclocked from the factory.)

    Today, it usually indicates that the GPU is actually a higher-end GPU chip that had some cores marked as bad.  So they disable those cores, put them on a lower platform name, and call it a "Ti" card.  It means it runs at the clock speed of the better card, has more cores than the regular model (but not as many as the better one).  It allows the company to reduce the losses from chips that come off the fab line with some small issues (a few CUDA cores are bad, etc.)  They have to design the chips in such a way that certain blocks of the chip can be disabled, but the extra design and circuitry is more than offset by the loss recovery.

    In fact, many of the cards today (1060, 1070, 1080) are all the same basic GPU, just some had failures in some blocks, so they disable those and put them in the lower spec card and at lower speed.  There may be ONE bad CUDA core in an nvidia GP-104 chip, but they have to disable the whole block of CUDA cores it is in.  So instead of being a 1080, it becomes a 1070 Ti.  If They have to disable two blocks of CUDA cores, then it becomes a 1070.  If three or more blocks have bad cores, it's probably a loss.  The 1060 has several tiers in it, and are GP-106 chips.  The 1080Ti and the Titan X and Xp are all GP-102 chips.  Just differing in how well they test coming out of the fabrication plant. 

  • Silver DolphinSilver Dolphin Posts: 1,638
    ebergerly said:

    It is unfortunate that Daz does not warn people that Iray is very hard on Video cards and really good cooling is a must with Iray or Octaine. Oh by the way I'm a Alienware User myself. I like the cool looking cases.

     

    While it might seem intuitively obvious that rendering/iray is "hard" on video cards, I'm not sure that's necessarily the case.

    Keep in mind that electronic components have a design life, and if you operate them, even continuously, within their "normal" design ratings (like temperature, frequency, etc.) they should last for their design life. A bit like how the human body can operate fine for over 100 years with a continuous temperature of 37C (98.6F). Which, BTW, isn't all that far from the temps some GPU's attain during rendering...

    So, for example, if during rendering your GPU temps get around 50C (which is probably in the "normal" or "continuous" rating), and it renders at that temp continously for a week, it should still last for its design life as long as the temps stay in the normal range. And if that design life is, say, 10 years, it's probable the GPU will be fine for 10 years. Doesn't mean it won't fail for some (other) reason, since everything has an unpredictable/probabilistic chance of failure (called "Mean Time Between Failure", MTBF).

    But whether you render for 1 minute or 1 week or 1 month at that normal temperature it doesn't (or shouldn't) really matter. The GPU's fan cooling is designed for it, and it's thermal protection is designed for it, and the components work fine at that temp.

    So yes, rendering raises the GPU's temperature, and it can be for a long time, but that doesn't mean it's a bad thing. Now, if you somehow exceed the normal range (which isn't easy if all is working as it should), and get near the GPU's "maximum" ratings, the GPU (and other electronic components) have built-in protection to either throttle performance, or shut down the computer so stuff doesn't get damaged. But the way the GPU is designed is to provide enough fan cooling so that this doesn't happen, and the temps should be continuously regulated to stay within the safe, normal, continuous range.

    So you'd need the fan/cooling to fail, and also the thermal protection to fail in order for meltdown. Unless you bought a poorly designed cheapo piece of junk I suppose.

    So if a GPU on a render machine fails it could be for many reasons, unrelated to the fact that it's used for rendering. If you want peace of mind, just monitor your temps while rendering to see if all is well. And if it fails during rendering while the temps are in the normal range, something else is probably going on.

    Nvidia video cards for consumers are designed for gaming not Iray. The fan profiles and cooling solutions are designed with this in mind. This is why even a really well build card with excellent cooling is gonna go over designed heating threshold when subjected to Iray. The way video cards are designed is like american cars they are built to break>> Consequently we are left with the need to do everything in our power to expand the MTBF life of our investment in these expensive video cards as best we can. Use MSI afterburner and open case and point a fan at computer to blow cool air at case especially during the summer months.

  • AnotherUserNameAnotherUserName Posts: 2,727
    edited June 2018
    ebergerly said:

    It is unfortunate that Daz does not warn people that Iray is very hard on Video cards and really good cooling is a must with Iray or Octaine. Oh by the way I'm a Alienware User myself. I like the cool looking cases.

     

    While it might seem intuitively obvious that rendering/iray is "hard" on video cards, I'm not sure that's necessarily the case.

    Keep in mind that electronic components have a design life, and if you operate them, even continuously, within their "normal" design ratings (like temperature, frequency, etc.) they should last for their design life. A bit like how the human body can operate fine for over 100 years with a continuous temperature of 37C (98.6F). Which, BTW, isn't all that far from the temps some GPU's attain during rendering...

    So, for example, if during rendering your GPU temps get around 50C (which is probably in the "normal" or "continuous" rating), and it renders at that temp continously for a week, it should still last for its design life as long as the temps stay in the normal range. And if that design life is, say, 10 years, it's probable the GPU will be fine for 10 years. Doesn't mean it won't fail for some (other) reason, since everything has an unpredictable/probabilistic chance of failure (called "Mean Time Between Failure", MTBF).

    But whether you render for 1 minute or 1 week or 1 month at that normal temperature it doesn't (or shouldn't) really matter. The GPU's fan cooling is designed for it, and it's thermal protection is designed for it, and the components work fine at that temp.

    So yes, rendering raises the GPU's temperature, and it can be for a long time, but that doesn't mean it's a bad thing. Now, if you somehow exceed the normal range (which isn't easy if all is working as it should), and get near the GPU's "maximum" ratings, the GPU (and other electronic components) have built-in protection to either throttle performance, or shut down the computer so stuff doesn't get damaged. But the way the GPU is designed is to provide enough fan cooling so that this doesn't happen, and the temps should be continuously regulated to stay within the safe, normal, continuous range.

    So you'd need the fan/cooling to fail, and also the thermal protection to fail in order for meltdown. Unless you bought a poorly designed cheapo piece of junk I suppose.

    So if a GPU on a render machine fails it could be for many reasons, unrelated to the fact that it's used for rendering. If you want peace of mind, just monitor your temps while rendering to see if all is well. And if it fails during rendering while the temps are in the normal range, something else is probably going on.

    Nvidia video cards for consumers are designed for gaming not Iray. The fan profiles and cooling solutions are designed with this in mind. This is why even a really well build card with excellent cooling is gonna go over designed heating threshold when subjected to Iray. The way video cards are designed is like american cars they are built to break>> Consequently we are left with the need to do everything in our power to expand the MTBF life of our investment in these expensive video cards as best we can. Use MSI afterburner and open case and point a fan at computer to blow cool air at case especially during the summer months.

    What card do you use?

    Ahh ok, just saw your signature.

    Post edited by AnotherUserName on
Sign In or Register to comment.