Secret Underground Train proportions?

Has anybody bought the new Secret Underground Train and can tell me whether it's scaled to standard gauge (say, similiar to Jack Tomalin's trains)? This might be a particularly nerdy problem, but I've grown suspicious of train-related stuff for DS and Poser - some of the products out there simply didn't bother with realistic standards, which becomes glaringly obvious once you try to combine vehicles or tracks from different artists. Anybody who already tried to measure the rail gauge or use it with other train products would be my personal hero of the day. wink

Comments

  • ZyloxZylox Posts: 787

    If you are concerned with realism, look closely at the promo images of the train cars where the wheels meet the rails.

  • nobody1954nobody1954 Posts: 933

    I plan on buying it. I'm concerned about the lack of a side window on the cab.

  • JazzyBearJazzyBear Posts: 805

    I plan on buying it. I'm concerned about the lack of a side window on the cab.

    Slap a plane with reflection on the side! They are using high-tech to see ahead any, LoL.

  • AbendwindAbendwind Posts: 44
    Zylox said:

    If you are concerned with realism, look closely at the promo images of the train cars where the wheels meet the rails.

    Good point there, although I'm looking for interchangeability rather than die-hard realism.

    I plan on buying it. I'm concerned about the lack of a side window on the cab.

    It doesn't seem to have a door either. surprise I could imagine the locomotive as a neat background model though.

  • McGyverMcGyver Posts: 7,085
    edited March 2017

    I don't own it but there seems to be something off with the tracks... Or the depth of the face of wheels to the flange.  The track seems a bit thick... But the locomotive wheels seem to look right... So I'm guessing the wheel depth is good, but in the first image with the locomotive, the wheel's flange mesh is intersecting the thicker rail... Or the cars and locomotive have different tracking/gauge widths... Or the loco/cars scale got messed up somehow between the different promo renders. 

    Realistically, under a certain price, with trains you don't see a lot of attention to certain details... It's like the different between a $30 New Bright Christmas train set and a $800 LGB set... Certain details are just close approximations mean to convey the gist of the look. The current sale makes the model a good bargain for what you get.

    Maybe the lack of side window is because it's meant to run underground and who needs to look at tunnel walls... Besides... Who needs another window for the zombies or C.H.U.D.s to break through... This is a secret underground base, it's a given something is gonna eat the engineer and the train will go hurtling through the tunnel to the dead end at the vat of explosive chemicals while the heroes/heroines battle the mutant whatevers while trying to escape.

    Edited to add... That's a good point... The window on the cab is the window of the door... Or where a door should be... 

    Transporter tech or Robo-Train.

    Post edited by McGyver on
  • HavosHavos Posts: 5,581

    I plan on buying it. I'm concerned about the lack of a side window on the cab.

    I suspect the interior has not been modelled at all, so adding windows and doors would have been an issue.

  • When I load the train or any of its components, they are not on top of the tracks.  If I move the train parts to the tracks, the tracks are much smaller than the train.  The tracks are inside the wheels. 

  • HeraHera Posts: 1,958

    I bought that product and it's missing files:
    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_BaseColor.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Height.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Normal.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Palette/Palette.dsf

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Barrel/Barrel.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_BaseColor.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Gaz Tank/Gaz Tank.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Roughness.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Height.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/electic box/electic box.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Normal.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Wood Box 02/Wood Box 02.dsf

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Wood Box 01/Wood Box 01.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Roughness.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Metallic.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/projector/projector.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/props_02_Emissive.jpg

  • L'AdairL'Adair Posts: 9,479

    I used the train for this image:

    Country Road

    It's been a while, but I don't recall having to do anything to make it fit the tracks.

  • NorthOf45NorthOf45 Posts: 5,692
    Hera said:

    I bought that product and it's missing files:
    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_BaseColor.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Height.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Normal.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Palette/Palette.dsf

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Barrel/Barrel.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_BaseColor.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Gaz Tank/Gaz Tank.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Roughness.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Height.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/electic box/electic box.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/Props 01_Normal.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Wood Box 02/Wood Box 02.dsf

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/Wood Box 01/Wood Box 01.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Roughness.jpg

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/missile_Metallic.jpg

    /data/Mely3D/SSB/projector/projector.dsf

    /Runtime/Textures/Mely3D/SUB/props_02_Emissive.jpg

    Are they not installed at all, or is a script complaining it can't find them? Those paths look valid, and my copy has everything you mention. Re-install?

  • pwiecekpwiecek Posts: 1,598
    edited November 2018

    I Don't know about the stand alone version, but the the bundle includes the track in the base, not the train.

    Here is a comparison with the Parkside Cargo & Freight Engines

    Engine Comparison.jpg
    800 x 864 - 435K
    Engine Comparison 2.jpg
    800 x 864 - 152K
    Post edited by pwiecek on
Sign In or Register to comment.